Peter Moore: Don't blame GPs for general practice issues


'If general practice fails, the hospitals face unsustainable pressure'
Any new Government will face an NHS crisis which cannot be sorted out without supporting general practice. If general practice fails, the hospitals face unsustainable pressure. It would not an overstatement to suggest that the health of the nation would suffer.
General practice is facing major problems. Why does it take so long to see a GP and why is so much online? The baby boomer generation are asking to “bring back the old type of GP”. As one of the last of the old-fashioned GPs and a baby boomer I understand their worry but also understand the difficulties for the present generation of GPs.
A compromise for general practice set up at the beginning of the NHS in 1948. It worked well at the time but, like the wonderful old phone boxes, it does not work in the twenty first century.
Before the NHS doctors’ surgeries were like a corner shop. People paid to see the doctor and he (and it was nearly always a “he”) owned and ran the business.
The first proposal was for the NHS to set up state run surgeries and employ GPs, but this was rejected by the doctors. They were afraid that becoming state employees would take away their independence. It would also mean that patients were allocated a GP with no choice. The final compromise was for GPs to remain self-employed running their own practice but being “subcontracted” to the NHS. This worked well for the doctors and the NHS at the time. It also worked for my generation but today it is no longer fit for purpose.
A new GP has to buy into a practice to become a partner. The partners own the building and pay all the running costs. Although this sounds expensive the NHS pays GPs a rent for the use of the surgery. All a new GP partner has to do is to ensure that the repayments on the loan match the NHS rent coming in and the books will balance. This is also cheaper for the government than building new health centres and paying all the running costs.
This system only works for doctors who plan to stay for thirty years. Anyone who has a mortgage will know that they only pay interest for the first few years. Anyone cashing in a mortgage after two or three years is likely to owe more than they borrowed.
The world has changed. In my childhood the doctor, bank manager, vicar and teachers were all there for life. Today people move around. Vicars are a part of a team ministry and bank managers have been replaced by cash machines and online banking.
The new generation of GPs do not want to be committed for thirty years. With the cost of houses today young doctors have a massive mortgage and a student loan. Asking a new GP for several thousand pounds to buy in and stay for thirty years is unrealistic.
Not all GPs are partners. A practice can employ GPs on a salary which works well for many of the doctors involved but it creates a problem for the partners who “own” the business. If no one wants to buy in how does a GP who has invested thousands in the practice over the years retire without losing a fortune?
Tony Blair’s government changed the law to allow anyone “of good standing” to buy into a surgery. I suspect that the plan was for private companies to buy out GPs. Today many pharmacies and opticians are owned by large companies who employ the professionals. Large companies looked at the funding for general practice and decided it was not viable. There would also be a political problem if GP practices were owned by large private companies. The alternative of the taxpayer buying every GP practice and building new health centres would be prohibitively expensive.
I do not have an answer except to suggest that an independent commission could look at this highly complicated issue. Whatever happens please don’t blame the GPs.