Peter Moore: Advancing years pose difficult dilemmas

placeholder image

I once received a message from a local vicar. His elderly organist, who was a patient of mine, was getting a bit past it and making mistakes. The vicar did not want to upset him and so asked me whether I could tell him that he should stop playing the organ as it was bad for his health. The only possible medical reason to stop playing would be for the health of the congregation’s ears. Did the vicar really want me to be dishonest? I explained that he had to confront the problem himself although I agreed it was hard.

I had a similar problem with elderly driving medicals. Occasionally I would be asked to check whether a very elderly person should still be driving. My problem was that this was a tick box exercise. Often the elderly driver did not have any specific medical reasons to give up driving like Alzheimer’s or poor eyesight. Tests for the speed of reactions were sometimes very good but I shared with the family a subjective feeling that this person should not be driving. If I failed them just because of my gut feeling they could appeal. I tried every argument. Buses are free with the bus pass or that it would be cheaper to take a taxi than the cost of running a car but often they were adamant. 

I was reminded of both these situations when I saw Jo Biden attempting to debate with Donald Trump. Apparently, he needs a crib sheet telling him how to get on to the stage and walk to the podium. His wife supported him both physically and mentally with the line that he managed to answer all the questions which seemed to me a minimum standard for the leader of the free world. 

As someone who has worked with very elderly people when I saw him struggling on stage I wanted to climb up, put my arm around him and say “why don’t you sit down and have a nice cup of tea” although being American perhaps I should have said coffee. 

Just like the organist or the elderly driver he seemed to have no insight into his own frailty and yet he is hoping to continue to have access to 3,708 active nuclear warheads with another 1,336 retired warheads which have not yet been dismantled for another four years.  Although an elderly driver might be a danger to other road users over 5,000 nuclear warheads are rather more dangerous. They are definitely more dangerous than a few bum notes during matins or evensong. Even worse, if the organist or the elderly driver had carried on it would not have guaranteed them another four years. 

We have had leaders who were unwell. Ted Heath had an underactive thyroid, although that was easily treated. Anthony Eden suffered a blotched gall bladder operation and was then prescribed drinamyl, a combination of amphetamines and barbiturates. This did not help his judgement over the Suez crisis after which he had to step down. Those around Churchill insisted that he had his own personal physician and, in 1953, he had a stroke. Amazingly this was kept quiet, not something which could happen today. Harold Wilson was developing Parkinson’s Disease when he resigned as Prime Minister in 1976. Luckily his alcoholic deputy, George Brown had already lost his seat.

At one time in America President Ronald Regan was developing dementia while the head of the CIA had a brain tumour. 

The American system of government is very different from ours. A Prime Minister is not a President but the leader of the largest party in parliament. As we have shown over the last few years prime ministers can be removed. 

It is difficult to persuade an elderly, proud person with no insight into their failing faculties that the time has come to leave the church organ or hang up the car keys. Sadly it appears even more difficult to suggest that perhaps being the leader of the free world for another four years is not realistic. 

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice