Paul Jolly: Rover rolls back years


Forty-four years separate these photos of the same man with his same car, albeit now bearing a private registration plate.
What is so remarkable is how well they have both aged, given the years that have passed.
West Country man Richard bought his Rover 3.5 (P5) from my old firm Hurst Park Automobiles back in 1980 from the boss, Michael Wooding, who still runs the firm to this day. I had recently left for a flying career with BA out of Heathrow so missed this transaction by a short time.


When P5 production ended in 1974, the new Rover SD1 was still under wraps but went on to become Car of the Year in 1977. Many will recall this capacious 5-door hatchback 3.5 V8 as the trusty white motorway police patrol car otherwise known as the Jam Sandwich due to its orange stripe down the side. Few speedsters ever got the edge over that.
The new Rover SD1 certainly modernised the fleet but suffered build quality issues that old-school Rover customers did not appreciate and which would never have plagued the outgoing P5 like Richard’s example. The simple fact is that the older car has outlived the newer one in terms of longevity, and SD1s are a rare sight now.
Ultimately, and as part of the giant BL conglomerate under Michael Edwardes, Rover’s true character became undermined with Honda’s involvement and models such as the 200, 400, Acclaim and the Rover badging of the Austin Metro all led to a disappointing downhill funnel.
Surviving all of this however are our gallant heroes as pictured, both looking timeless, classy and true classics. But who has aged the best and wins the test of time?
I reckon it’s a tie!