Torquay’s history of tricksters, forgers and false identities explored in fascinating look at deception


From fake Jack the Ripper threats in St Marychurch to an international art forger operating from Torquay, a new historical reflection explores the extraordinary stories of deception, fraud and fiction hidden within the Bay’s past.
We are a storytelling species. Some stories we invent are to entertain, others explain natural phenomena, human behaviour, or give us moral lessons. Some of us, on the other hand, tell tales to deceive and we can only speculate about their disparate motives. In 1888 a series of murders took place in the East End of London and were blamed on an unidentified killer who became known as Jack the Ripper.
That year Torquay's court was told that the Reverend Samuel Harvey, a retired clergyman living in St. Marychurch, had received threatening letters. Most of the contents were not made public as the language was deemed “too disgusting” for public consumption. One letter said, “My God I’ll cut you up from head to foot; I’m the Whitechapel Murderer”. Charlotte Higgins, the 14-year-old servant of the house, claimed to have even met the Ripper face-to-face when a man had visited demanding, “Open the door or by God I will murder you.” In response to these threats, the Reverend asked for police protection and was given an overnight guard. Soon, however, Charlotte confessed to being the author of the letters and of inventing her Ripper visitor. She was subsequently convicted and sent to prison for three weeks and then to a reformatory for a further three years. Yet, many locals saw the sentence as unfair: “The decision of the Bench was received with loud hisses by the public in the body of the Court.” We will never know why Charlotte held such a grievance against the Reverend, or why local people were so supportive of a teenage servant girl. Some stories can be elaborate and designed to deceive. Indeed, there are those whose entire lifestyle seems based on a series of financial fictions. In December 1864 a Count Ostragoe made acquaintance with Edward Windeyer, the Catholic priest of the Church of the Assumption of Our Lady in Abbey Road. The ‘Count’, however, was soon arrested after being exposed as a Russian-born professional con man by the name of Michael Ostrog.
According to court reports: “The prisoner has been in town for a month and under a variety of pretences, had managed to defraud very many persons. Amongst others he ingratiated himself into favour with the priest, to whom he declared himself to be a ‘gentleman’. The priest aided him with his advice, and frequently gave him a good dinner. “At one of these dinners the ‘count’ said beer did not agree with him, and accordingly the priest drew out a bottle of claret for the delectation of his distinguished guest. The said guest smacked his lips over the claret, extolled the canon for his hospitality, and said he expected a handsome present of wine from his friends abroad in a few days, of which he would give his entertainer half a dozen bottles. Half a dozen of famous claret was soon stored away beneath the hospitable roof of the presbytery. It was afterwards discovered that this wine had been obtained not from the count’s friends, but from Mr. Gee’s wine office.” Michael had then told the priest that he had “cigars to the value of £70 or £80 in the Teignmouth Custom House, and the duty amounted to £20 and a few odd shillings. Towards this he had £17; would the kind-hearted canon lend him just enough to make up the balance, which he swore should be paid next day.” Of course, no cigars appeared and the priest suspected fraud. In the style of GK Chesterton’s fictional amateur detective priest Father Brown, Father Windeyer “took a policeman with him to the count’s lodgings, and after climbing up interminable flights of stairs, came to the topmost room of all, which served alike as bed and dressing room to the count. The policeman put his knee to the lock and forced it open, and there was the count in an interesting condition, much astonished at such a singularly inappropriate visit. The prisoner was also committed for stealing a silver-plated pint cup from the London Hotel.
The cup had been missed from the sideboard in the hotel after one of the count’s visits, and was found beneath his bed after he was taken into custody.” Michael went on to commit many more crimes, mainly fraud and theft, and in 1887 was certified insane while in Wandsworth prison. In 1900 he was sentenced to five years imprisonment for stealing a microscope. The last we hear of Michael was in 1904 when he entered the St. Giles Christian Mission in Holborn after leaving Parkhurst prison. Other criminals just seem to have stumbled into an opportunity and then simply went with the flow. One was Torquay antiques dealer and skilled restorer of old furniture James Edward Little. To help with the bills, James and his wife let lodgings during the summer months, and it was due to a guest in their home that he began his illicit career. In 1900 a London art dealer named JB Russell stayed at the Little’s Torquay home. Russell came upon some Pacific and Australasian curios and offered to sell them for James.
A profitable little business then followed. This may have given James the idea to embark on a new venture, that of selling Māori and Polynesian artefacts. He placed advertisements in the Exchange and Mart newspaper, beginning one of Britain’s first antiques mail-order businesses, and soon had a string of serious collectors as clients. The only problem was that they weren’t genuine Māori and Polynesian artefacts. James, who had never set foot in the South Pacific, was for decades one of Europe’s most notorious art forgers. He went on to fool art collectors, scholars, and museum directors across the world, including the Chicago Field Museum of Natural History. He even sold fakes to experts and collectors in New Zealand, where many of the pieces were supposed to have come from in the first place. All believed that his forged or stolen artefacts and their associated documentation were real examples from indigenous peoples, rather than from the back room of a dodgy Torquay dealer. James's best forgeries were often copies of authentic Maori art. He would steal these from museums, replace them with fakes, copy the pieces, and sell the originals on. As he preferred to do all his transactions through the mail, none of his clients ever saw him, even though they may have been dealing with him for over a decade. However, while an accomplished forger, James wasn’t a master criminal. In 1915 he stole a decorated Māori wooden box from a Wiltshire museum, substituting the original for one of his fakes.
The swap was noticed and, though he had signed the visitors’ book with a false name, he was the only visitor the museum had in three days. He was quickly arrested and sent to prison for six months. James went to prison again in the 1930s for attempted theft from museums and auction houses. Yet, he was never actually convicted of forgery, the crime for which he became notorious. People lie for an assortment of reasons. Maybe to avoid punishment, for revenge, to obtain rewards, to impress, or to avoid being judged. Some lie for no ‘good reason’, are careless, impulsive, or even compulsive dissemblers. Yet, lest we become too cynical and untrusting, each day many of us fib and fabricate. We are a social species and want to make others happy and so by far the most common reasons for being economical with truth are altruistic. And perhaps there are often no clear dividing lines between fact and fiction, except in motivation and consequences. As Torquay visitor Oscar Wilde commented, “The truth is rarely pure and never simple.” The same applies to untruths.