Motoring with Paul Jolly: Rishi Sunak puts the brakes on smart motorways


Rishi Sunak has cancelled all future development of smart motorways with immediate effect under public pressure about safety concerns. This is a decisive and welcome move which will stop any new construction but will not necessarily reverse existing stre
Rishi Sunak has cancelled all future development of smart motorways with immediate effect under public pressure about safety concerns.
This is a decisive and welcome move which will stop any new construction but will not necessarily reverse existing stretches.
The issue here is that stranded vehicles are left in a running ‘live lane’ which used to be the hard shoulder and now depends on the immediate actions of monitoring staff to spot the broken down vehicles and ‘Red X’ the lane in question.
This theoretically prevents use of that lane to protect the stationary motorist.
There are two distinct types of smart motorway - 'all lane running' where all lanes are in permanent use and 'hard shoulder running' where the lane is controlled dynamically as required, typically in rush hour loading.
The latter only permits use of the hard shoulder in very heavy traffic and where speeds can be controlled with overhead signage and cameras.
Initially, safety refuge areas were planned every half a mile but in practice, is more than double that distance thus reducing the likelihood of reaching one when needed.
Smart motorways were, on paper, a great idea since the cost per mile to incorporate the hard shoulder as an extra lane was one tenth the cost of road widening when taking into account land acquisition and bridge widening.
It also took just two years per sector rather than ten years to build.
But motorists have not taken to the concept and with the dreadful record of fatalities involving HGVs ploughing into stationary cars, something had to give.
Existing routes are unlikely to change back but more can be done and the technology already exists to improve safety.
The Saltash Tunnel west of the Tamar bridge has red/green running lights to allow switching the 2/1 lane configuration for alternate rush hour.
'All lane running' can convert to 'hard shoulder running' and have full length red/green lighting embedded in the road with increased signage alongside. More refuges can also be installed.
Unless your car is on fire, you must keep going to the next refuge area.