Labour's housing drive raises Torbay home building targets, but questions remain


Angela Rayner's building bonanza has seen Torbay's annual house-building target go from 599 homes to 997
Housing targets in Torbay and across Devon are set to increase significantly, as Labour’s Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government Angela Rayner unveiled ambitious plans to build 1.5 million homes over the next five years.
The collective total for Labour’s local targets would be just over 370,000 homes a year, up from the Conservative’s target of 300,000 homes a year.
Angela Rayner said that the reforms will “correct the errors of the past and set us on our way to tackling the housing crisis.”


Under the government’s new method, Torbay's annual house-building target has gone from 599 homes to 997. The average number of homes built between 2020/21 and 2022/23 was 341. Over the whole southwest, 40,343 homes should be built each year, up from 28,203.
To help deliver 1.5 million homes over the next five years, councils will have to review their green belt land if needed to meet their own target, identifying and prioritising ‘grey belt’ land.
Cllr Alan Tyerman, Torbay Council’s Cabinet Member for Housing and Finance said that although there was a national shortage of housing in the country, there were issues with the viability of delivering housing in a region such as Torbay.
“In Torbay, we are beginning to run out of viable sites to build on,” said Cllr Tyerman.
“You can find a few, but a lot of those that remain are exceedingly hilly and difficult to build on. What we find with a lot of remaining land that should be able to create 500 houses can only viably produce 200. I didn’t read much from Angela Rayner about this issue of viability.”


Cllr Tyerman said: “When you look at the old Nortel Site, it’s a wonderful brownfield site that could be built on, it’s derelict and the owner is not building on it and there’s permission to build there. But, like many sites that are earmarked for housing, the owners are not coming forward.
“From the point of view of a commercial business, you can understand that, but in terms of meeting our housing needs, it makes no sense at all.”
Cllr Tyerman said that while Torbay Council did own some pockets of land near Preston Down Road, Little Blagdon Farm and Colliton St Mary, they are relatively small compared to what’s needed. Other areas of land are important green spaces in the Bay, such as Cockington Country Park.


“Devon’s problems are not unique, but they are also not the norm,” he commented.
“In Torbay and across Devon, we have an issue of under-occupancy, where people are still living in a house they lived in for their family that’s got lots of bedrooms.
“Then you have the problem, from a housing point of view, of second homes and Airbnbs.”
He continued: “In terms of housebuilding, you can’t just build housing estates down little country roads where cars can't pass each other. There are so many areas in which housing in Devon would need such enormous changes to road structures and the cost of that would be prohibitive.”
He added: “My overall view would be that nationally there is a shortage of housing. That shortage of housing is driven by a number of things and I think we need to be addressing them all.”
Cllr Tyreman stressed that a Devon-wide approach was needed, and that was exactly what would happen with the newly established Devon and Torbay Combined County Authority.
“We’re getting the nod that this is likely to proceed. Whatever happens there, housing was meant to be a big issue of funding within the combined authority, and Torbay will be very much involved in that. The combined authority will be well positioned to produce the necessary levels of housing across Devon, not worrying so much about traditional authority boundaries.”
With a new Local Plan in the works, it’s likely that further details as to how Torbay will accommodate increased housing targets will emerge in the coming months.