Jim Parker: Torbay's voice now more important than ever - as well as partnership working


Torbay’s boundaries will be extended under a councils shake-up
I must admit that I have never spoken to Teignbridge Council leader Richard Keeling, but I was mightily impressed with our debut chat.
Local government reorganisation was the topic of our conversation and it was obvious that talking and partnership working will be key and absolutely essential if the government’s new way of running council services across Torbay, Teignbridge, South Hams and the rest of the county is to stand any chance of working.
Under the LGR shake-up Exeter and Plymouth will see their boundaries extended to become new unitaries. So, too, will Torbay whose expanded, new unitary area will now include 17 Teignbridge towns and villages including Teignmouth and Newton Abbot and four from the South Hams including Kingswear, Marldon and Stoke Gabriel. The rest of the county will fall into the coast and country unitary.
What the new Torbay-based authority will be called is anybody’s guess - Torbay and South Devon, Greater Torbay, Greater South Devon or whatever. What is clear is that this is not being seen as a ‘Torbay takeover’ and working together in the future will be crucial.
That message came out lead and clear from the latest meeting of the strategic Torbay Leadership Board.
“It is a partnership of equals,” said Torbay’s Liberal Democrat MP Steve Darling at the meeting. “This needs to be seen as a partnership across South Devon. It is not a takeover.”
Chief executive Anne Marie Bond also emphasised: “Torbay will be a key contributor, but this will be a brand-new authority.”
Teignbridge leader Cllr Keeling and his Torbay counterpart, Dave Thomas, have been talking for some time.
He says: “I have known David for about two years as leader and during that time we have had several meetings including Team Devon.
“This option chosen by the government is not one that we chose but we are committed to working together.
“I have had a meeting with David just to touch base and to make sure that David understands that this is a new entity, it is not a continuity. We are on an equal footing. David agreed with that.”
He said the two leaders will now be working together organising the elections for a shadow authority next year.
He added: “Myself and David have a good working relationship. I have also of course been talking to Steve Darling (Torbay MP) and Swithin Long (Torbay Lib Dem leader).”
He is a county councillor and sits on the Devon/Torbay Combined Authority. Plymouth have now indicated that they want to join them clearing the way for a strategic elected mayor to sit above the new Devon unitaries set-up.
He said: “We are very interested in having as Mayor. New Prime Minister Andy Burnham coming to the fray is rather good for Devon. If that is the case it brings more money to Devon. We will make this work for the residents of Teignbridge and Torbay.”
Much of the new LGR shake-up has been focussed on a ‘Place’ strategy and what towns and area have to offer as a place - Torbay is way ahead of the game with its Placed-based policy and its Torbay Story. and the Torbay Leadership Board
Cllr Keeling says names have been bandied about a new name for the new unitary.
He insists: “Nobody will lose their identity. It’s a place. We are lucky to have Andy Burnham who understands this.
“Place is very important because we have set out five priorities within Teignbridge. We will align them with Torbay. We will work together as one unitary.”
Those priorities are based on Community, Economy, Environment, Homes, and Infrastructure.
Like Torbay, Teignbridge has local regeneration projects to get over the line - one of their most high profile has been the modernisation of Market Hall in Newton Abbot. There will be a race against time to see these projects in both areas completed or at least started.
South Hams Council leader Dan Thomas was far from happy with the LGR decisions.
He was quoted as saying: “Once again, the Government has demonstrated its failure to understand or appreciate the needs of Devon’s rural towns and villages or our coastal communities.
“Its decision to go ahead with the expansion of Plymouth, Exeter and Torbay is very much at the expense of the remaining parts of the county, and entirely at odds with its stated aim of ensuring local government reorganisation meets the needs of all of Devon.
“It has failed to implement its plans for the devolution of powers and decision-making to local areas, while ploughing ahead with the reorganisation of local government, which has the potential to undermine the foundations of local democracy and service delivery for years to come.
“Throughout this process, we have made a clear and consistent case that reorganisation must protect the identity, needs and voice of our local communities. I know that many residents in the affected towns and parishes will be concerned about what this means for them, and I understand that. South Hams has a distinctly rural and coastal character, and the interests and priorities of our communities must not be lost in the transition but protected for future generations.”
He was quick to add, however: “We recognise the significance of this decision for our residents, businesses and partners across the region, and our priority now is to ensure a smooth, well-managed transition that protects our essential services.
“We will work closely with Devon’s other councils and the Government to secure the best possible outcomes for our communities, ensuring that local identity, local priorities, and local voices remain at the heart of local government here in Devon.”
Cllr Thomas told me: “I already have a good working relationship with Richard at Teignbridge as we are both county council cabinet members. I am having meetings with Dave Thomas to look at the areas in the middle borders
““I am still very disappointed at the outcome. I really want the government to release the results of the consultation that took place.”
He said that he was at a loss how a ‘mandarin in Whitehall with a felt pen’ could decide that serving the best interests of South Hams residents was to separate into different unitaries and areas the likes of Dartmouth and Kingswear and Totnes and Berry Pomeroy
But he said: “If it’s going to work it’s going to work with people being on side. I have no problem with working with any of these people.”
Devon is already looking at a judicial review to overturn the LGR decision but at the moment it appears others are prepared to work together for that new unitary future and it’s odds on that that future will include a strategic authority and mayor.
Torbay MP Steve Darling said there is ‘too much power at Westminster’ - mayors would devolve that power down to the regions.
Torbay Council leader Cllr Thomas, said: ”The direction of travel from the government is for mayors providing strategic oversight. It is the only game in town. If you want to be at the table you will have to have a mayor. It will be nothing like the old elected mayor in Torbay!”
His deputy Chris Lewis agreed: “A mayor will be more strategic and will look after things like transport, skills and education.”
As for Joe Bloggs, he conceded: ”Most people will be unaffected and will still only be worried about their bins being collected, potholes and weeds. In Torbay it will be business as usual.”
I don’t think he’s far wrong…