Jim Parker: Time to shake hands on new future at Torbay Council

Council meeting could provide 'momentous' moment in the way Torbay is run

Frank Sinatra did it his way and if local councillors can agree to do it the 'Torbay Way' we will all be quids in!

This week's Torbay Council meeting could provide a momentous moment in the way our Bay is run, a moment which, fingers and everything else crossed, will see the leaders of the three groups at the Town Hall shake hands and agree on a new way of working TOGETHER.

For far too long relationships have been strained across the council chamber, with some people more concerned with political point scoring than getting on with the job they were elected to do.

In recent weeks and months tempers have flared, especially over the sorry saga surrounding the selection of the civic mayor, which has reached silly proportions and even a lengthy and costly councillor standards hearing.

Believe it or not, behind the scenes and amid all the shenanigans, councillors of all persuasions and colours were taking part in a 'facilitation' programme which was aimed at bringing them closer together and at least talking to each other.

The initiative came from a Local Government Corporate Peer Challenge of the council in April 2024 which highlighted the need for “pragmatism on the part of political leaders to find common ground on the top strategic priorities that must be determined and delivered collaboratively.”

It recommended the council find ways of working effectively in a context of the minority Administration No Overall Control arrangement. 

The LGA report highlighted that “political tensions and the way they are being played out are negatively impacting on staff morale and motivation, the vast majority of elected members, the reputation of the council and the trust and confidence of partners.”

It added: “The issues are vested in a very small number of elected members, from across the Council Chamber, who must ask themselves what they want their legacy to be — in a context of this being that ‘moment in time’ for Torbay.”

Common sense has at last prevailed and out of all this has emerged a Leader’s Agreement, which all three groups have said they will sign at the full council meeting on Thursday.

‘'Good Governance the Torbay Way' is the banner under which the Bay will be run once the agreement is signed.

“All group leaders recognise there will always be a need to work together to ensure the good governance of the council, which is built on trust and for the best interests of the council and the residents it serves, irrespective of the political make-up of the council,” says a report to the meeting.

“To enhance the good governance of the council, the respective roles of administration and opposition need to be clearly understood, defined and supported and expressed in our constitutional arrangements. 

“The group leaders have worked together to co-create the changes required to both the constitution and our ways of working to embed effective administration and opposition in our ‘Torbay Way’ for good governance.”

The key elements to the new Torbay Way of working will be the clear roles of an administration and opposition. There will be a ‘shadow cabinet’ to mirror the council leader’s cabinet and opposition councilors will chair audit and scrutiny committees so they can hold the administration to account.

Oh and by the way, the administration get to nominate the mayor and their deputy!

The report says: “It is also in the interests of local people that there is a working relationship between the leader of the council and other councillors, members and between political groups.

“The relationship between the leader of the council and other members and between the political groups will also be supported if all members adhere to high standards of courtesy and mutual respect in their dealings with one another.

“It is important that robust debate of the issues at stake does not deteriorate into personal criticism of another person who holds a different point of view. Courtesy, respect and civility must be maintained at all times. Fellow elected members must not be subject to name-calling, personal criticism or abuse.”

Council leader Dave Thomas said: “There is a complete agreement. We are going to sign it. The council needs an administration and it needs an opposition. We will remain in administration; we will have the mayor and deputy mayor within our gift.

“We are going to enhance the shadow cabinet and give the opposition scrutiny leads so they can hold us to account.

“All group leaders have come together to make a plan. It does not happen overnight. It has taken us since the pay review to get it all in place.”

Liberal Democrat leader Swithin Long said: “It is a first step. There is lots of other stuff which needs to change as well but it is encouraging that we will be moving forward.

“There are all sorts of stuff to sort out like social media and information sharing which could be done better, but it is a good first step.”

Independent group leader Darren Cowell said: “It is a significant step forward. It formalises working arrangements. It recognises the roles of administration and the roles of an opposition.

“It will prevent the issues we’ve had recently with the mayor vote in particular. There is not just for this time. It is about moving forward. It is quite unprecedented in terms of formalising the role of administration and opposition.

“It gives the opposition the roles of audit and scrutiny. It is right that the opposition marks the homework of the administration.

“We had to do something. This was destabilising for council staff and officers.

“Other benefits are that Torbay can work more closely together and has a united voice.

“With local government reorganisation we need to be focusing on a united voice selling why Torbay is such a successful council.”

All I can say is Hoorah! I know there will be many more bumps in the road to come, but at last it would appear we have everybody singing from the same hymn sheet at such an important and pivotal time in Torbay's history.

More on that next week — let's get that blooming agreement signed first...!

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice