Jim Parker: There's no 'I' in Team and that's crucial right now for Torbay


Delegation returns from investment conference after stealing the show
The tightrope that governs the political balance and key to power in Torbay has just got tighter.


The Furzeham-with-Summercombe member has suddenly become one of the most popular people in the Town Hall because he holds the key to decision-making and at one of the most crucial stages in the Bay's history.
A Torbay delegation has just returned from Leeds and one of the country's biggest conferences and exhibitions, where the Bay stole the show in so many ways. One thing it had on its side was a united voice and front when promoting and selling the resort to potential investors and new business.
But back home, Cllr Hutchings's decision threatens to put the kibosh on all that. Were we in for another round of merry-go-round politics, more musical chairs when it came to leading important committees and could we even see the dear old mayoral chain of office change necks again?
Hopefully not, on all counts...
Cllr Hutchings first said in a statement that he felt he was being ‘held back’ and unable to speak his mind, although he has said he will still support what the Conservatives were doing in Torbay.
His resignation from the group leaves the Conservatives with 17 councillors, plus him as a so-called 'Conservative-leaning' independent. The opposition group of Liberal Democrats and independents has 18 councillors.
In practice, a number of important recent debates have split down party lines, and have been decided on the casting vote of the mayor — currently, and in the recent past, a Conservative.
If Cllr Hutchings votes with his former Conservative colleagues, the Tory administration can be sure of holding sway. If on any issue he decides to vote with the opposition, the Conservatives will lose. Even if he decides to abstain, that would also be bad news for the Conservatives.
He said the decision to go independent had been on his mind for a while, saying it was hard to criticise decisions and ‘work ethics’ of fellow councillors while in a group.
He added: “Certain things aren't getting done and are being brushed under the carpet. Now I can lift the carpet and deal with the issues.”
He claimed some 'local issues' were being ignored and he was not content to tell local voters that they were just ‘being worked on’.
Cllr Hutchings said: “The Conservative group has made some tough decisions over the last two years – some I'm not fully on board with – but it has managed to achieve some really good projects as well.
“I’m hoping to work with council leader David Thomas and the Conservative group along with the Lib Dem group and fellow independents to iron out the problems this council is facing. Local councils shouldn’t be so political and now being independent I don’t have to tow the party line and can ask questions against all sides of the chamber to get the right result for my residents.”
Cllr Hutchings told me: “I have left the group officially and sent all the necessary emails. I am quite a popular man. They have all come out of the woodwork.”
He revealed: “I have spoken with Dave Thomas and said I do not want any positions changed. He will still be the leader and the mayors are still in place and everything else.
“The Lib Dems have not said much. They have messaged me to say well done. Darren Cowell (from the Independents) has also been in touch but just to point me to governance and their services.”
He insisted: “I am not going to be politically swayed. I do not want to be part of any political coalition. The way I vote will depend on what I am voting for. There will be a slight change of committees because of the political balance. I get to sit on what committees I might want to but I’ve told Dave Thomas he will stay as leader and everybody else can stay as they are.”
He said he was behind the Tories and the Bay's regeneration programme, adding: “For the bigger projects they are doing good, although some could be done slightly better. It is just that I feel that I could not question some of the decisions being made. I wanted to be able to ask questions for some of the things the Tories are doing but I was not getting any straight answers. It was getting too political. It was point scoring after point scoring. I have never been like that and I do not want to be like that.”
He said it was the 'smaller issues' that were of concern.
“It was the little things like the bylaws in Brixham harbour not being enforced. My residents are harbour users and are asking questions. I feel that I can now ask questions from both sides and I can get the right answers for my residents.”
Tory group leader Cllr Thomas said it was 'fundamental' that group discussions are held and the way forward is agreed so that everybody is happy to support it.
“We have a collective responsibility,” said Cllr Thomas.
He added: “At the annual meeting of the council there was a real go at Hazel Foster. I said to the group that we are not going to get involved in this. I'm trying to get that message across regarding Facebook. We are taking the brunt on Facebook all the time, but I said it’s not worth getting involved. Some members are upset about that, they want to have their say but I'm saying this is not going to help, it is just going to inflame the situation.
“I can understand where Jason is. I am disappointed he is taking the decision that he has taken but I am pleased that he’s still committed to what we want to deliver. He has said he likes the stuff that we are doing. We have made a great start. Lots of stuff is coming through in the pipeline.
“Regarding the smaller issues, the council does not operate at the same speed that someone in business operates. The council is a democratic body and these things take time.”
He added: “When you are operating a minority administration the last thing you want is upset. We have a big regeneration programme and I am absolutely determined to deliver that programme. Our relationship with Jason will be key to that.”
Cllr Hutchings is the third member of the Conservative group to jump ship since the last full council elections in May 2023. Katya Maddison and the late Patrick Joyce left the group to form Prosper Torbay later that year.
Earlier this year he was the subject of a complaint when he re-posted a Facebook post from Reform UK, which is against Conservative party rules. However, he said he was not leaving the Tories to join Reform.
“I’m staying as an independent for the meantime, but who knows what’s around the corner?” he said. “But I don’t see myself being a Conservative again as the party hasn't brought anything new forward.
“I have made this decision as I feel that my residents will have a stronger voice and from all the messages and phone calls and comments I have received, residents are over the moon I have decided to make that decision.”
The Torbay delegation that has just returned from Leeds and the UKREiiF event can hold its head high. With 16,000 people attending and dozens of other local authorities trying to persuade an army of potential investors to part with their money, the Bay was up there with the biggest and best of them. Hands up, I have a conflict here because I was privileged to be part of that Team Torbay.
It was a non-stop four days of talking to countless people attracted to the Torbay stand by what we had to offer and a bag of savoury fish and chips, a bottle of Bays beer and the chance to win a short break at Beverley Holidays in Paignton.
Torbay unveiled its development prospectus detailing its key development sites and opportunities alongside private sector partners Willmott Dixon and Milligan. There were receptions, fringe meetings and panels of experts talking regeneration and investment. Torbay, already with more than £200million of public and private sector funding in the bag, was there with other VIPs in front of people keen to find out why a small authority like Torbay and the Torbay Story had achieved so much. And there were the private conversations between Bay leaders and potential investors which may yield some great outcomes in the not too distant future.
I know for these people it is their job to do what they are doing and they get paid for it. But I can say with hand on heart that for them this is more than a job, It is a determination, a passion to see the Bay succeed and move forward.
As Cllr Thomas said: “We saw such positive things at UKREiiF. If I could take every member of the council to UKREiiF so they could feel the positivity that exists for Torbay and where Torbay is moving and the speed with which it is happening it would be eye-opening. People just want to be in the same place that we are. Everybody wants to be part of Torbay.”
That is why it is now more crucial than ever before that our councillors of all colours remember to make sure Team Torbay stays as one.