Jim Parker: Regeneration schemes should be a subject to a collective view


There always has to be a balance between conservation and preserving the past and developments which are supposed to yield a better, 21st century future. Yep, you heard it here first - Jim Parker, 'Mr Regeneration' putting in a word for history and heritage.
But, and there had to be one. is preserving a site or building the right course of action if it is currently doing more damage to that very environment it is supposed to be protecting and conserving in the first place ? And who should have the say in that - council officers or councillors elected by you and me and paid to act in our best interests?
Take, for instance, Mark Wright and his Majestic Tours, one of our most successful and resilient holiday companies. Mark and Majestic unveiled £3million regeneration plans recently. They bought an empty and rundown former casino next door to their Templestowe Hotel in Tor Church Road at the top of Torquay town centre. After spending £1million on refurbishing and carrying out essential repairs to the former Genting casino, they came up with a proposal to transform the building with an 'Aparthotels' scheme - a cross between a hotel and self-catering apartments - which would link with the Templestowe next door.
But the scheme has been refused - not by the planning committee, but by a planning officer under 'delegated powers' and who cited 'design and heritage' issues with the proposals.
Council leader Dave Thomas and his deputy Chris Lewis say they both asked chairman Katya Maddison to let the full planning committee decide on the casino plan but she refused, opting instead to go with the officer's decision.
Cllr Thomas said: "I asked for the scheme to go to planning. That request stays with Katya. She refused to take it to the planning committee and said it should stay with the officers."
With due respect to people who live there, the area isn't the most salubrious in town. The casino was empty and falling down before Mr Wright bought it. Bedsits abound and other accommodation nearby is, let's say, wanting.
Cllr Thomas said: "This is a £3million investment from somebody in the town who wants to do great things to make Torbay move forward. It is great that Mark has bought the casino and is now investing this kind of money.
"But it was deemed to be detrimental to the conservation area. One officer looked after the application. I was trying to get it to the planning committee to obtain a collective view. I was trying to let the elected members have a view and have a say. If they had said there was merit in the scheme but it needed some more work and a tweak then fine, but it did not go that far."
As for the design of the new building and its impact on the immediate neighbourhood, Cllr Thomas said: "Nobody looks down on the scheme. A passing seagull may have seen it. You would have to be 30ft tall to see it from the wall behind."
The owners of Mollys Cafe at Paignton harbour were faced with the same issues recently. Their plans for a glass canopy were originally earmarked for refusal after an officer's recommendation on heritage and overdevelopment grounds, but the difference here was that they went to the planning committee who decided to defer the application pending some revisions.
Then we have the Hotel Virginia in Falkland Road, Torquay. Plans to demolish it and replace it with 14 apartments were refused - at least by the planning committee this time - because of heritage and conservation issues. The former hotel, two Victorian properties pushed together, is rotting, beyond saving and a magnet for anti-social behaviour.
Cllr Thomas also pointed out: "The Hotel Virginia is a brownfield site in the middle of the town. It is not a heritage space. If we cannot get brownfield sites over the line for redevelopment it puts more pressure on greenfield sites."
His deputy, Cllr Lewis was more scathing in his reaction to the demise of regeneration projects. He said: "These schemes are prime examples of people who want to invest in Torbay. It is an absolute disgrace that the casino development wasn't allowed to go to committee. And if people want to build on brownfield sites and save greenfield sites you have to make difficult decisions. There are difficult decisions being made. We are going back in Torbay and not delivering and deliver we have to."
Cllr Maddison was one of two councillors first elected as a Conservative in the last local elections who then broke away from the then ruling Tory group to form the Prosper Torbay group. Her colleague at the time and who joined her - Patrick Joyce - sadly passed away last weekend.
Cllr Maddison has the Lib Dems and Independents to thank for making her planning chairman after the Conservatives lost control and the right to appoint such roles. It was always rumoured that she was very keen on conservation even when it came to regeneration. But she emphasised to me: "I am very supportive of the regeneration process."
And she added: "Torbay hasn't always got heritage right in the past. We now have a team in the Planning Department with useful heritage experience and need to listen to them. The more consistent our decisions, the better it is for applicants because then they will know what tends to work and what not, and I really encourage applicants to help prevent disappointment by taking their proposals through the pre application process, which can save a great deal of heartache."
Cllr Thomas says: "I understand there is a place for conservation areas. There are times when conservation is absolutely key - like with the Pavilion, Torre Abbey and Oldway. But we are not looking to build 14 apartments on Torre Abbey Meadows!"
If you were, would the planning committee decide or Katya Maddison and a planning officer?