Jim Parker: Nobody dare mention the 'D' word but our beloved Pavilion is in a perilous state


It really is coming to crunch time for the Pavilion and the un-thinkable has to be in the minds of some people - can the grand old lady on Torquay seafront actually survive for much longer after years of dereliction? Owners Torbay Council are locked in b
It really is coming to crunch time for the Pavilion and the un-thinkable has to be in the minds of some people - can the grand old lady on Torquay seafront actually survive for much longer after years of dereliction?
Owners Torbay Council are locked in behind-the-scenes talks with tenants and marina company MDL over the lease for the historic building - trying to take back control is believed to be one of the favoured options for the Town Hall.
But time is on no-one's side not least the listed, landmark building which is slowly slipping into the sea.
Surveys will no doubt confirm the sorry state of the Pavilion, but the cost of scaffolding and repairs are literally going through the roof. A £2million contribution from the £22million Town Deal funding pot won't even touch the damp-ridden sides.
And when and if the repair work is carried out what of the future? As far as I am aware and at least not publicly, nobody seems to have come up with a suitable use for the site which can sustain its long-term future - in other words a use that can generate income.
My fellow Torbay Weekly columnist and Torquay businesswoman Sally Allen has just raised the future of the Pavilion. I am in no way, stealing her thunder but her idea of an Agatha Christie centre at the site is something I have raised, albeit only in passing, several times.
Sally has gained some support for the idea after she raised it on social media. She wrote: "The council has asked for ideas on how to develop and use the Pavilion - as Torquay is Agatha Christie's birthplace, but there is nowhere (as far as I know) in Torquay that is dedicated to her and her achievements, wouldn't it be good to turn the Pavilion back into a theatre and museum dedicated to her.
"Her plays could run continuously and as there are so many to chose from, this could be an endless cycle. Just think how long 'The Mousetrap' has run in one theatre? There would also be room for a museum too with a supporting gift shop all dedicated to Torquay's most internationally famous resident. The project would create great PR opportunities worldwide, which in turn would increase tourism."
Support was quick to roll with. Well-known local commentator Jack Critchlow replied: "I wrote an opinion piece a while ago advocating just this. The Agatha Christie Pavilion would have a lecture room cum cinema, a museum, book/gift shop dedicated to AC and her genre; and a themed bar/restaurant."
"I love this idea" was another comment.
So, too, was: "This is something I've long said." As well as: "That’s the way it started and nothing else has succeeded since."
And "Great idea, it would also bring in more tourism of Agatha Christie fans."
"Marvellous idea for Torquay’s most iconic building. Hopefully our councillors will finally see sense and bring our beautiful Pavilion back to life," said another.
Another remembered past days: "I remember seeing Cliff Richard and Petula Clarke.Loved it as a theatre."
TV presenter and personality Judi Spiers joined the debate and said: "It'll never happen Sally... firstly it's such an inspired and yet obvious idea...secondly its not their idea."
And some support from far away: "From across the pond in Southern California, I personally have been a very big Agatha Christie fan most of my life. Super idea."
I have always maintained we don't do anywhere near enough to make the most of Dame Agatha - the Bay's most world-famous daughter. We even managed to knock down the house in Torquay where she was born.
It was interesting to see Carolyn Custerson, chief executive of the English Riviera BID Company which is officially sponsoring this year's Agatha Christie Festival, commenting.
She said: "Totally support this idea Sally and I proposed this 12 years ago but the problem is how we fund such a multi million project. The building is now in such poor condition. Let’s not give up. As the world's biggest crime writer an Agatha Christie Heritage Centre could be absolutely fantastic and attract visitors from all over the world."
Carolyn hits the nail on the head. A Christie centre would be great but who would finance such a massive project - and make sure it pays its way in the future?
The Torbay Civic Society was born out of past battles to save the Pavilion from demolition.
Current president Ian Handford has some grave fears for the future of the building again.
He says: "There is little doubt that Torquay Pavilion is now in a desperate situation. During its long history our council has seen fit to threaten to demolish this building on no less four times when on each occasion our society was forced to come to its aid. On the first occasion during the early 1970s, the council wanted to use the site to construct a new conference centre, which led to our former president, Mrs Sheila Hardaway, establishing a supportive group to save the building when setting up Friends of the Pavilion which eventually became Torbay Civic Society after she made it a charity.
"Years later the council closed the building again until it was eventually turned into a shopping centre and finally under the new leasees MDL it was finally closed again. Today, I believe we currently await the outcome of a surveyor, who must report on the situation of the supporting metal rods encased within concrete structure which at the time of the former hotel plan was believed would have involved costs of around £3 to £5 million to make the structure safe and meet health and safety standards. If the surveyor now finds the metal has deteriorated further the likelihood of more than £8 to £10 million might need to be spent before the building becomes "fit for any purpose" - a staggering amount of expenditure for any potential investor.
"Sadly, the problem of finding a sustainable (financially) use for the buildings is what has deterred investors for many years and of course this now includes MDL who chose to close its many shops internally and give notice to all leaseholders. If the surveyors report actually discovers the roof or the main structure have now reached a point of no return then sadly even our long supportive society, will have to agree the building must not remain as an historic listed eyesore in perpetuity. "
Ian mentions the hotel scheme. It would be remiss of me if I didn't. The multi-million project including the refurbishment of the Pavilion as a concourse for a quality hotel with shops, restaurants and a high-level block of apartments is well-documented. So, too, is the successful battle from campaigners to blow the plans out of the water primarily saving a small piece of Cary Green open space.
Good luck to them I say sincerely. Cary Green was saved and a block of apartments is no longer a threat to any sky line But where was plan B in all this? Nobody dare mention the 'D' word here, least of all our politicians looking to the May local elections and not wanting to lose votes by the mere, dreadful thought of demolition.
But, make no bones about it, the Pavilion is in a perilous state. I just hope again sincerely that we aren't left with just Cary Green...