Jim Parker: Name-calling is unhelpful with Pavilion deal now so close


I had the honour of speaking at a special meeting the other night. It was about heritage, the Bay's heritage.
Now I am no expert in the field of heritage and culture. I feel more at home kicking a ball around or trying to still see and hit a cricket ball.
But I am interested in how we can make the Bay a better and more vibrant place to live in, work and visit and our heritage has a huge part to play in that.
The meeting was with business and community leaders and National Lottery Heritage Funding representatives. Torbay has been chosen to work with the NLHF and its Heritage Places Strategy to look at opportunities that could be unlocked in the resort.
The 'Places' core to the strategy fits in neatly with the Torbay Story which is the Bay's toolkit for promoting and selling the Bay especially to potential investors by championing what a great 'place' we live in.
Our Naturally Inspiring and natural environment is a big selling point - the meeting was at the Imperial Hotel from where the beauty of the Bay and our UNESCO Geopark glory was there for all to see.
Then we have our cultural assets and dare I mention Oldway Mansion and the Pavilion. Both have been left by different Town Hall political regimes to virtually rot over the years which, I am sure, everybody will agree is a disgrace.
The current Conservative leadership at Torbay Council has made great play of bringing these historic gems back to life.
Indeed, around £ 8 million of government Levelling Up funding has been directed towards Oldway and some restoration work is at last underway at the former mansion home of the Singer sewing machine family.
But what of the Pavilion? There in lies another story, a story which has taken a new twist only this week. It was back before Christmas that Tory group leader Dave Thomas and his deputy Chris Lewis were proclaiming the dawn of a new era for the Torquay waterfront building after tenants and marina company MDL 'agreed' to hand back the lease of the Pavilion to the council so it could be in control of its future.
Fast forward to the last week or so and it would seem the celebrations were a little premature as last-minute legal negotiations were holding up the actual transfer of the lease, which was due on September 30.
Opposition councillors and campaign groups like Save Torquay Pavilion had a field day.
One commentator said: “Do any of our supporters remember when a newspaper (it was the Torbay Weekly, by the way) featured Cllrs Thomas and Lewin proudly announcing that a deal had finally been agreed for MDL to hand back their lease on the Pavilion? This was published in December 2023! As Mark Twain said: “It is better to keep your mouth closed and be thought a fool than to open it and remove all doubt.”
“P....s up in a brewery” and claims the council didn't want the Pavilion back because then they’d have to look after it was just some of the other comments.
Some were personal and in my opinion over the top - even MDL took the rare step of saying in an official statement: “We appreciate the community's keen interest in the future of the Torquay Pavilion. The handover process has proven more complex than initially anticipated and we're focused on ensuring a thorough and proper transfer. This short extension is necessary to finalize all legal aspects and ensure a smooth transition and MDL Marinas is very much committed to the council to do so.
“We hope to be able to put out a shared and positive statement with the council next week and thank all our customers and the local community for their patience.”
Cllr Thomas told me: “I understand how frustrating this is for people. It is absolutely frustrating but we cannot get it wrong. These things take time but it will be worth the wait. Anybody buying or selling a house will know things don't always go smoothly. It is no different doing a property deal in the council. People have said we said a deal was struck in December. We did strike a deal but we did not have lawyers in the room and now at the 11th hour it is a case of dotting the 'Is' and crossing the 'Ts'."
The current leadership are determined to give the Pavilion a new life. Once the deal with MDL has been finalised - keep those fingers crossed - the council plans to start work 'from Day One'. Funding from the Town Deal pot of cash will go towards work to protect the outside of the building, like making windows vandal-proof. Then the plan - just like Oldway - is to bring in experts to assess the damage and size of repairs needed to make the building fit for purpose. I am led to believe that steel poles literally hold the building up. Let's hope they are still up to the job.
Expressions of interest as to the future use of the building are still open. Cllr Thomas reveals: “We have had everything suggested from community use, cultural, the arts and entertainment.”
What would be his dream scenario for the Pavilion? He says: “For it to be restored to its original glory with a usage that is attractive to locals and visitors from all over the UK and is successful enough to look after itself.”
It would be fantastic if those people so frustrated that they are making uncalled-for and quite nasty comments - and that's not all the comments by the way - could refocus their energy on making a new Pavilion actually happen.