Jim Parker: Labour's new house building targets give us a hill to climb

placeholder image

Who mentioned the words 'new town'?

Hold on to your hats, Torbay is faced with some tough, game-changing decisions on building new homes with some of our most cherished green spaces even under threat.

Angela Rayner, Labour's newly-elected Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, has dropped a bombshell on local authorities like Torbay by setting them new annual housing targets.

The Bay's new annual target has gone up from 599 homes to 997. The average number of homes built between 2020/21 and 2022/23 was 341. Putting it in black and white, the Bay will have to provide 20,000 new homes over the next 20 years.

There is an acute housing shortage and crisis across the UK and nobody will disagree that in 21st century Britain everybody should have a roof over their head. But the million dollar questions are where are these new homes going and who is going to pay for and build them?

The new government says that to help deliver 1.5 million homes over the next five years nationwide, councils will even have to review their green belt land. Cllr Alan Tyerman, Torbay Council’s cabinet member for housing and finance, is quoted as saying: “In Torbay, we are beginning to run out of viable sites to build on. You can find a few, but a lot of those that remain are exceedingly hilly and difficult to build on. What we find with a lot of remaining land that should be able to create 500 houses can only viably produce 200.”

Another big issue for Torbay is that the owners of many sites ripe for development are not coming forward. He adds: “In Torbay and across Devon, we have an issue of under-occupancy, where people are still living in a house they lived in for their family that’s got lots of bedrooms. Then you have the problem, from a housing point of view, of second homes and airbnbs.”

Council leader Dave Thomas said: “We need to produce a new Local Plan to produce these numbers. When the last Local Plan went out for consultation there were some sites residents did not want to lose. 360 homes a year was being required then. If you triple that number the impact in Torbay will be huge.”

He said part of the way forward was working with partners and neighbours Teignbridge and South Hams.

“We have two main roads, one to Totnes and one to Newton Abbot but both these areas are outside Torbay's boundary,” said Cllr Thomas. But he added: “Torbay is not on its own. Teignbridge and South Hams will be in a similar situation.”

He said the process will probably take a couple of years. Any new Local Plan will have to conform with Neighbourhood Plans for a start. Firstly a list of all potential development sites will be drawn up to consult on with residents. Then comes the interesting bit - a finalised list to actually meet the new housing numbers which are odds on not going to go down with some people as they see cherished pieces of land given up for development.

“If we are being honest there will be some sites included that were previously ruled out,” says Cllr Thomas.

Councils can offer up 'extenuating circumstances' as to why they may not be able to reach the new homes numbers. The Bay's naturally built environment would not be seen as one.

“If you have a national park that is also no reason to drop numbers,” says Cllr Thomas.

He added: “There will be some challenging times ahead. Once the guidance is issued our first step is to have a conversation with government to see if we are going to be held to account for the extra numbers because our area is so small or is it something for the Combined County Authority and working with Devon.

“The government is saying that green spaces that were sacrosanct can come forward but they must include 50 per cent social housing.

“The authority can give planning permission for all these new houses but the reality is who is going to build them? Where is the money coming from to build them?

“We have sites at places like Nortel in Paignton and the former Hollicombe gas works site at Preston where there are housing schemes but homes have not been built. The council also has a handful of sites likes Crossways in Paignton and Union Square in Torquay but there is a viability gap.”

The council has only recently agreed a proposal for a sensitive greenfield site at Paignton. A developer will be allowed to put fewer affordable homes on the site to allow the council to build more badly-needed homes elsewhere.

“It’s all about trying to get a reasonable receipt for the family silver,” said Cllr Nick Bye.

The bay’s cabinet voted unanimously to allow future development at Preston Down Road to include the mandatory 30 per cent of affordable housing rather than the 50 per cent set by the council last year.

The council had wanted more cheaper homes for local families than the national guidelines lay down, but they heard that insisting on the higher level would mean the project would become unfeasible for developers, leading to the land not being developed at all.

New homes won't only be difficult to deliver - they also add to the already under-pressure schools, health services and road networks.

But expect to see more controversial green field decisions like Preston Down Road - and I wouldn't even rule out talk of a 'new town' type development.

As Cllr Thomas says: “We don't want to do this but we don't have a choice. It is going to be difficult.”

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice