Jim Parker: It was going to be the five-star icing on the cake - now it's a mess

placeholder image

It was going to be the icing on the cake, Torbay's pride and joy, giving us back a long-lost five-star status and putting the English Riviera on the map with a massive, positive message. Now all we could end up with is homes - don't get me wrong, we need

It was going to be the icing on the cake, Torbay's pride and joy, giving us back a long-lost five-star status and putting the English Riviera on the map with a massive, positive message.

Now all we could end up with is homes - don't get me wrong, we need new homes in the Bay, but at this site and at the expense of a sensational new spa/resort hotel?

I refer, of course, to the site of the former Palace Hotel in Babbacombe.

We were saddened to see the once-glorious and four-star Palace raized to the ground. But, tired, ageing and in need of massive investment and refurbishment, its demolition seemed a small price to pay as the giant Fragrance Group, led by Singapore-based billionaire James Koah moved in with their eye-watering, grandiose regeneration plan.

They were even given planning permission to build 37 new homes where the Palace's indoor tennis courts once stood, to enable or finance the five-star dream. Now that's all it is a dream!placeholder image
They were even given planning permission to build 37 new homes where the Palace's indoor tennis courts once stood, to enable or finance the five-star dream. Now that's all it is a dream!

A press release from the Fragrance Group was issued with the headline: 'Palace Gardens to provide homes for Torbay families'.

It went on to reveal: "A proposal for a new luxury five-star Palace Hotel is being withdrawn because changing economic circumstances mean it is no longer financially viable. In its place are plans for new homes to alleviate Torbay’s chronic housing shortage.

The new plans for the site in Babbacombe Road include a proportion of affordable homes for local families."

Martin Rogers, of Global Hotels and Leisure Consultancy, said on behalf of the Fragrance Group: “When we first unveiled the vision for a new Palace Hotel with some new housing four years ago, no one could have predicted how different the world would be in 2023.

“While work on the new homes element of our earlier proposals is progressing well, it has to be said that the figures for a replacement hotel simply no longer add up. Too much has changed. Torbay Council has recently assessed the local hospitality industry and worked out that there is already an oversupply of accommodation.

"At the same time, we know that many people in the sector here are struggling to recruit enough workers. There are around 200 vacancies in hospitality in and around the Bay.

"So, Torbay is not short of hotel bedrooms, but what Torbay is very short of is homes. There is a housing crisis in the area and our new proposals will go some way to alleviating this"

He added: "The site on Babbacombe Road is brownfield, well connected to the road network and close to a wide range of local facilities, so it is an excellent location.

"The original 2019 plans to replace the old Palace Hotel included the 37 new homes on the site, which are well on the way to being completed. The new proposals include a further 67 new homes, of which a proportion will be designated as affordable homes for local people. The proposed new development is called Palace Gardens II."

The backlash was predictable and immediate once the press release hit the public domain. What didn't help was the timing of the release - just the morning after a supposed hush-hush briefing to councillors when they were told to stay mum about the whole thing.

There was also some disquiet after it was revealed that the Fragrance Group and their representatives had been meeting with the Town Hall hierarchy before the briefing to members. I gather that this was to make sure any new housing plans met with current Torbay Council policy - namely there was a provision for affordable homes. But it still didn't look good.

And as for the supposed 'over-supply of accommodation' claims, they were aimed at the lower end of the hotels/B&B market and definitely not the top end where tourism leaders want to see more.

It wasn't long before Torba MP Kevin Foster was on the warpath. He said: "This is a shock and deeply disappointing, potentially ending the chance of an iconic job creating development for our Bay. When seeking planning permission The Fragrance Group repeatedly stated the housing on the former tennis courts was merely an 'enabling' development for the hotel plans, now they have done a U-turn on this assurance.

"This site is a unique location, including its grounds, and at the very least other hotel companies and developers should be offered the chance to purchase the site to take forward a plan which better reflects its longstanding usage, rather than simply accept an assertion from the current owner that a lucrative housing development is the only option.

“I appreciate the need for more affordable housing and for Torbay Council to improve its lamentable record on delivering it, which saw only 23 new affordable homes delivered in the year 2021/2 and only 15 in the first six months of 2022/23, despite its own target to deliver 180 a year. Yet it only takes a walk through Torquay Town Centre to see opportunities for development of new affordable homes on long derelict sites, something which should be the first priority before releasing a unique site like this.”

Swithin Long, the councillor in charge of tourism and regeneration, said: "I think that it confirms that there are increasing costs in construction etc. It is affecting everybody - in the private as well as public sector. It is confirmation of what is impacting the economy."

He could not remember if there had been linkage between the two elements of the scheme.  But he did reveal: "The council are seeking independent advice on the viability issues. We will wait for the advice and take it from there."

Quite frankly and sadly,  I can't see that making a difference and I would be very surprised if there was any legal agreement stipulating that the early tranche of 37 homes could only be built if the hotel was delivered.

Even if the council, who already don't build as many homes as they should, turned down a new planning application what's stopping Fragrance from going to appeal and winning?

Martin Rogers said: "The Fragrance Group remains committed to Torbay – the new Mercure on Paignton seafront is now open and work on the neighbouring Ibis Styles, and the replacement for the old Corbyn Head Hotel in Torquay, are progressing well.

"The group is now preparing to discuss the proposals for Palace Gardens in more detail with the local community and a range of other stakeholders later in the year before submitting plans to Torbay Council for its consideration."

And that's what makes it doubly sad. Fragrance's huge investment in the  Bay is in danger of being overshadowed by the mess that is the Palace.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice