Jim Parker: Here's what former mayor Gordon would do with Living Coasts - bonkers or brilliant?

placeholder image

Well, was he brilliant or simply bonkers? It's the question I posed to you last week after a rather outside-of-the-box idea from Torquay businessman Mark Hoyle over the future of the cuurently-empty Pavilion and Living Coasts sites in Torquay. He has su

Well, was he brilliant or simply bonkers?

It's the question I posed to you last week after a rather outside-of-the-box idea from Torquay businessman Mark Hoyle over the future of the cuurently-empty Pavilion and Living Coasts sites in Torquay.

He has suggested slowly but surely taking the Pavilion to bits and rebuilding it brick-by-brick at the former marina aviary and transforming it into a Minack #2 open theatre. There would be a bit of Agatha Christie thrown in with another famous name from the past, Isambard Kijngdown Brunel, remembered back at the Pavilion site which would also include some kind of low-level development (I'm assuming residential) and an underground carf park.

Brixham businessman Andrew Strang said: "I think that is a great idea.  What an amazing use, the site has almost the correct shaping for it. Imagine the water and laser shows which could be created. Similar to future o scope in France."

Linda Dickinson added: "Would be marvellous if they could pull it off!"

Steve Clinton feared: "Seems a great idea to me but there will be objections. You can bank on it."

And Simon Robinson took us back in time with a "Rebuild the Marine Spa" call.

Davd Hodson thought Mark Hoyle was indeed bonkers and came up with his own interesting idea for the prime site.placeholder image
Davd Hodson thought Mark Hoyle was indeed bonkers and came up with his own interesting idea for the prime site.

He said: "Bonkers! The Living Coast is such a crucial site, visible from around the bay, land and sea, close to harbour, marina, beaches etc. It needs an iconic style building or structure to give a character, identity, to make a statement about the area. Branding and association. Consider effect of spinnaker tower, Syd opera house, angel of North, the dome etc as beneficial impact on local area. Very probably picking up on sails in marina or local marine life in design. Bold and brave design which will be controversial but notable. The Pavilion is quaint, faded glory of a less revered historical time. Keep as history and a distinctive use, and Brunel museum for engineering sounds good. But moving it to the other site?!"

And finally to a name from the past and the world of local politics - former elected mayor Gordon Oliver, no less

He says of Living Coasts: "Formerly the site of the Marine Spa, demolished in 1970, but it is now being considered again for alternative uses.   After Coral Island was demolished, the site remained empty for 14 years.  That should not be allowed to happen again, particularly with the Pavilion now closed and Debenhams about to be demolished.

"I strongly believe that the best way forward is to landscape the whole site as a public open space with a restaurant and event facilities, and including an additional  one acre site in front of Living Coasts which is already approved in the Harbours Plan.  The beach, Beacon Cove, a south facing popular spot should remain open with public access permanently made for local people and holiday makers to use.

"When Coral Island was built, the Council included in the development Beacon Cove which sealed the beach off so there was no public access.   There was a huge outcry and a petition went to Court and the residents won.  By this time the developer had already sealed up the access to the Cove and that is why we finally had that tortuous route into Beacon Cove because the structures newly made sealing the beach off to the public had to be demolished.  So public access must be maintained.

"It is not an easy site to develop, as we can see from its past history.  In the 1980s the council at that time found itself in difficulty finding a developer so they offered an extremely long lease, I think over 100 years in length, with no rent payable, with a developer providing the capital and expertise to develop the site, which was the final outcome.

"The council should create a prime public open space on the site, beautifully landscaped, ideal for maritime and other events, which would be extremely popular amongst all ages   It would give this sensitive part of Torquay seafront a long term future as opposed to a number of developments in the last 50 years, which, strictly speaking, have not been financially successful.   And it permanently creates continuous public access to Beacon Cove.  Opening it up from Beacon Quay as one major route to the Cove, as well as a disabled friendly access on the other side, would finally create a beautiful link-up and a lovely walk along the whole of Torquay seafront."

Is our former esteemed mayor bonkers or brilliant? The debate goes on. Over to you again......

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice