Jim Parker: Could the Pavilion be our Minack... on the Living Coasts site?

placeholder image

There is a saying somewhere about having to be mad to be brilliant or something like that. Anyway, what ever the saying one thing is for sure - Mark Hoyle is either bonkers and brilliant or just plain bonkers. Mark has entered, not for the first time I

There is a saying somewhere about having to be mad to be brilliant or something like that.

Anyway, what ever the saying one thing is for sure - Mark Hoyle is either bonkers and brilliant or just plain bonkers.

Mark has entered, not for the first time I hasten to add, the growing debate over the future of the Pavilion building on Torquay seafront.

Negotiations between landlords Torbay Council and tenants, marina company MDL, are still dragging on leaving a huge question mark over the future of the empty site.

A total of £2milliion has been earmarked from the government's Town Deal funding pot for Torquay to help pay for repairs to the landmark building, paving the way for it to be brought back into some kind of use.

But as the lease talks continue, so does the damage caused to the building with the repair bill increasing and still no definitive long-term use in site.

Mark was one of those against a Pavilion regeneration project a few years ago which would have seen it refurbished as part of a Nicolas James Group four-star hotel complete with shops, restaurants and a literally highly controversial tower block of apartments.

At the time his solution was to dismantle the building brick by brick and rebuild it on an island in the middle of Torquay harbour!

Now his latest idea is even more outlandish and eye-popping - again demolishing the Pavilion slowly but surely but this time plonking a rebuilt Pavilion Two on the currently empty Living Coast site just across and around the other side of of the harbour. Its future is also up in the air after being closed as a marine aviary by the Wild Planet Trust (Paignton Zoo) during the pandemic.

Mark is convinced the former Living Coast site would make a fabulous Minack Theatre #2 - Torbay's very own version of the world-famous open-air theatre which sits above a gully with a rocky granite outcrop jutting into the sea at Porthcurno, just four miles from Land's End in Cornwall. There could also be a touch of the Agatha Christie's with a visitor centre there.

Back at the old Pavilion site that could be transformed into an Isambard  Kingdom Brunel attraction to recognise the 19th century civil engineering 'giant', described as 'one of the most ingenious and prolific figures in engineering history' who built among other things the Great Western Railway and had Brunel Manor at Watcombe in Torquay designed as his country home although he died before it was completed and is hardly celebrated for his South Devon links, together with a low-level development and an underground car park.placeholder image
Back at the old Pavilion site that could be transformed into an Isambard  Kingdom Brunel attraction to recognise the 19th century civil engineering 'giant', described as 'one of the most ingenious and prolific figures in engineering history' who built among other things the Great Western Railway and had Brunel Manor at Watcombe in Torquay designed as his country home although he died before it was completed and is hardly celebrated for his South Devon links, together with a low-level development and an underground car park.

Mark says: "It's time for some honesty in Torquay. I still have the surveys on the Pavilion from years ago and it was a desperate situation even then. It's not only the steel frame that's a problem."

He sent a 'cut and paste job' of how the Pavilion would sit on the Living Coasts lad, saying: "I thought you might like to see how the Pavilion would fit on the Living Coast site to create a Minack Theatre #2. Imagine sitting listening to an orchestra with the beautiful Bay as the backdrop and all under cover."

He adds: "I know just about everyone in Torquay thought I was completely bonkers suggesting the Pavilion Island idea a few years back but it actually addressed the issue of the town actually earning its way out of its current decline rather than waiting for the next  hand out.  Bournemouth Council loved the idea but didn't have a harbour to build an island in.

"Some honesty needs to be brought into the Pavilion issue. In truth the building was never meant to be where it stands today and moving it would provide the opportunity to develop a fantastic all weather mixed development on the current site incorporating an enclosed inner Plaza, underground car park; the development itself creating the funds needed to rebuild the Pavilion with a brand new steel structure on the Living Coast site. And of course being built on reclaimed land, the Pavilion's  rusting framework is probably the least of the buildings problems in years to come.

"The Pavilion building is the first of its kind in the UK; a forerunner of the many warehouses you see on industrial estates all over the UK.  There's nothing stopping it being carefully de-constructed and rebuilt in another location."

Mark says his solution would tick so many boxes by using the current Pavilion land and creating a Pavilion Mark Two with a completely, new world-class attraction for Torquay and the Bay.

He emphasises that this is not pie-in-the-sky or something on a whim - he has research to back the idea some gathered during his Pavilion Island days. And talking of that time and just to set the record straight, he insists that his business interests had nothing to do with his opposition the apartments tower block. He works for a company providing holiday cottages. He was involved with plans for a holiday accommodation development in the Rock Road area overlooking the Pavilion site. He maintains views from the development would not have been impacted by the potential tower and its value would have increased. The project never went ahead.

He likens the concept of the Pavilion rebuild to the 'magnificent Flying Scotsman', explaining: "Sounds like a steam train, smells like a steam train and looks like the beautiful Flying Scotsman when it was originally built. Not bad for something that is 85 per cent brand new. Haven't heard that many people complaining about that rebuild."

He insists: "Wake up to the opportunity. Time to have a very frank discussion."

Bonkers or brilliant - you decide!

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice