Jim Parker: Commissioner Hernandez doing her best to make Torquay town centre safer but is a BID only way forward?


Traders snub new Bay high streets crime fighting 'tool'
What is the saying 'you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink'.
Crime Commissioner Alison Hernandez must be feeling a little like that at the moment.
Like it or not, the Commissioner cannot be accused of not trying to clean up and reduce crime at the top end and Castle Circus area of Torquay.
Working with other key partners like Torbay Council and the community safety partnership, she has invested time, energy and a lot of money into various schemes to try to make the area a safer place by tackling drugs, anti-social behaviour and shoplifting.
Police raids and arrests, hotspot policing, more officers and patrols, street marshals, new dispersal orders, a mobile cop shop and a Street Focus: Torquay initiative are a few of the anti-crime measures introduced.
Yet, the latest tool to help traders in particular fight crime has gone down like a lead balloon
A new way of reporting crime through an online secure portal or smartphone app has been funded in its first year by Mrs Hernandez and her Office of the Police and Crime Commissioner.
Year Two it will cost traders £20 a month. Trouble is only a handful right across the Bay and not just Torquay have signed up in year one when it’s free and it’s feared nobody will want it when they have to pay for it next year.
Mrs Hernandez says: “Retail crime and in particular theft and shoplifting is a serious concern across our communities — not only for the businesses directly affected, but for residents, visitors, and anyone who wants to see vibrant, thriving high streets.
“It’s not just about financial loss. Crime and antisocial behaviour in our town centres damage confidence, discourage footfall, and impact people’s sense of safety.
“That’s why I’m proud to announce the launch of a year-long pilot in Torbay, funded by my office, to provide businesses with free access to the UK Partners Against Crime Business Crime Reduction Solution.
“This innovative initiative gives local traders a powerful, user-friendly platform to report shoplifting, antisocial behaviour and other criminal activity quickly and effectively.”
The UKPAC system enables businesses to submit incident reports, share intelligence, and work collectively to tackle persistent and repeat offenders.
“This shared approach allows police to build stronger, more detailed evidence files and to target their resources where they will have the greatest impact and reduces the time police officers have to spend building legal case files for court,” says Mrs Hernandez.
“This initiative forms part of my wider Street Focus: Torquay programme, a multi-agency effort involving Devon & Cornwall Police, Torbay Council, SWISCo and others, focused on addressing the deep-rooted issues affecting Castle Circus and the town centre more broadly.”
She emphasised: “Retail crime is not an isolated issue. It affects entire communities. When a business experiences repeated shoplifting or abuse of staff, it takes a toll — not just on profitability, but on morale, safety, and the willingness of businesses to invest in our towns. “That’s why I see supporting our business community as a core part of my mission to keep Devon and Cornwall safe.
“With UKPAC, we are empowering traders to be part of the solution. Rather than asking small business owners to fill out time-consuming reports or chase follow-ups, this system simplifies the process. In just a few clicks, incidents can be logged, images and footage uploaded, and relevant information shared across the network.
“More importantly, this information doesn’t just sit in a file — it becomes actionable intelligence. Patterns emerge. Repeat offenders can be identified more quickly. And crucially, it enables high-quality case files to be built that improve the likelihood of prosecution and conviction.”
Businesses that sign up to UKPAC also benefit from access to discounted crime prevention tools and services — providing further support to protect their staff and premises.
Mrs Hernandez says: “It’s a joined-up, practical approach to crime reduction that fits hand in glove with our broader partnership work in Torbay.
“By improving how we report, track, and respond to these crimes, we are sending a clear message: crime against businesses in Torbay will not be tolerated.”
She said Inspector Rob Harvey and his neighbourhood policing team are already seeing the benefits of working with partners to tackle the issues affecting the high street.
“By incorporating data from UKPAC into their patrol planning and enforcement activity, they can target their efforts more effectively and respond faster to emerging problems, “ says Mrs Hernandez.
She has high hopes of the new Torbay initiative being just the start of a new way of cracking down on crime and says: “This is just the beginning. My vision is that this pilot in Torbay will serve as a blueprint for other areas across Devon and Cornwall. We want to see our town centres bustling, welcoming and safe — places where businesses can thrive and where residents and visitors feel proud to spend their time.
“If you are a business owner in Torbay and have been affected by crime or antisocial behaviour, I urge you to sign up. It takes just a few minutes to get started, but the impact could be long-lasting. Together, we can build a stronger, safer, and more resilient community.”
All she has to do now is persuade the traders.
One told me: “This is tricky. As much as I support it in some ways, shops are hesitant to go for it. It is funded for a year. What happens then? It is £20 a month which is quite a lot of money when you are talking about little independents or head offices who will not pay that amount of money.”
This trader has had experience running a town centre anti-crime project with businesses using a radio network and a ‘banning’ offenders scheme. But there was a difference. “That was funded by the street market," he reveals. “It was a membership scheme. If you wanted to ban people you had to be a member.”
He added: “This latest scheme in Torbay is just an app on its own. What you need is leadership. The council was going to appoint a town centre manager but I am not sure what happened to that.
"You need somebody leading, somebody oiling the wheels and keeping up the momentum and getting people on board. It is about a bit of shoe leather.
"The businesses want more than just an app and loading a picture to a portal. There are also some who will say 'what is the point because the police never turn up'. I am just playing Devil's Advocate.”
Currently there is a radio scheme run via a network in Wales which is linked to the council’s CCTV control room. The trader said: “It is information sharing and more useful than an app.”
He can, however, remember when a similar CCTV linked and banning system was run in the Bay’s town centres and paid for by the traders in a levy as part of a BID (Business Improvement District).
He said: "With the old BID we had something like that. But the retailers did not want to continue with it.
“With a BID you would have some leadership and management of the town centre. It is proven that a BID attracts investment and investors. It is like having a Blue Flag on a beach."
It surely has to be something to consider in the not too distant future. A regenerated town centre has to be a safe town centre as well.
That’s why I hope Commissioner Hernandez doesn’t run up the white flag just yet….