Jim Parker: Carnage looms for Brixham - could this be just the start of things to come?

placeholder image

Just a few weeks ago I highlighted Torbay's housing crisis. In a nutshell we haver fewer and fewer pieces of land available for new homes. At the same time Torbay Council is struggling to meet government targets to build new houses and more and more peopl

Just a few weeks ago I highlighted Torbay's housing crisis. In a nutshell we haver fewer and fewer pieces of land available for new homes. At the same time Torbay Council is struggling to meet government targets to build new houses and more and more people desperately need a roof over their head.

Residents have been warned some tough decisions lie ahead and even some green spaces may be under threat from development. Meanwhile, developers are bound to latch on to the government targets dilemma as they look to build on sites and seek planning permissions.

Now, as you an see from my track record, I am the last person to stand in the way of regeneration, new homes and progress.

But the issue here is planning appeals being decided by inspectors who will be faced with facts and figures but with little or a limited feel for the local environment.The consequences could be dire. In one case disastrous for Brixham in particular.

The council was dealt a blow when a government-appointed inspector allowed an appeal by developers Abacus-Deeley Freed for the Inglewood development including 373 homes, a pub and primary school on land alongside Brixham Road, between White Rock and Galmpton.

The developer appealed after the council failed to meet a deadline to make a decision on the planning application. The planning committee later decided it would have refused the scheme. It said the development would harm the nearby South Devon Area of Outstanding Beauty and go against the Brixham Peninsula Neighbourhood Plan.

But the inspector said the council could not show it had identified enough housing sites to meet its three-year or five-year building targets. He ruled the benefit of the new homes outweighed the harm to the landscape.

That may have appeared bad enough. But now absolute carnage looms as details of the roadworks needed for the development emerge. They will see a large section of the main Brixham Road in and out of the fishing port closed and Brixham virtually cut off from the outside world for months on end next year with traffic chaos and the local economy decimated.

Brixham Chamber of Trade says on its website: "Our chamber is very concerned by proposed plans to close the Brixham Road for a large chunk of 2023, to allow road alterations as part of the Inglewood development.

"The initial closure from January 3 to May 12 (excluding Easter) has the potential to be enormously disruptive and at peak times could effectively cut Brixham off from the rest of the country. "

Evidently, the plan is that  from January 3 until a ‘planned’ date of May 12, Brixham Road will be closed from Windy Corner to Lidl, except for a two-week gap at Easter.

Beyond May 12 there will be ongoing work, with traffic management in place at times, and then a further week of road closure at the end of the works.

And from mid-May until the end of October a further series of road works are planned at the Long Road and Windy Corner junctions with traffic flowing under traffic management.

The plan is to divert traffic down through Goodrington and out along Dartmouth Road.

The chamber is concerned the diversion will not be able to cope with traffic and have asked for more evidence of the remodelling of vehicle flows.

"We are asking the developers to show us clear data-driven evidence that the roads will flow freely throughout this road closure, if this happens, our primary concerns will be dealt with," says the chamber.

The chamber also has  'grave concerns' about the impact that an accident or unscheduled roadworks on Dartmouth Road would have, if it overlapped with the Brixham Road closure.

"This would cut our only remaining road out of the town," says the chamber.

It adds: "The impact of getting it wrong, and effectively cutting Brixham off from the rest of the country, is too serious to ignore.

"Our concerns relate to the impact on traffic flows if Brixham Road is closed We are very concerned about the impact of these works on traffic flows in and out of Brixham, especially at peak times.

"Every day of the year there are queues in both directions around Windy Corner and at times the whole of this length of Brixham Road can be full of queuing traffic.

"It is not just Brixham residents who rely on the road: it is the main artery to Dartmouth; one of the main routes for school children to South Devon College and Churston Grammar School; the route through which our fish is transported."

Holiday parks in Goodrington could also be hit.

The chamber says: "Our peninsula town relies on the tourists which visit us along the road. Commuters pass in both directions every day. We fear that the diversion proposed in the developers’ plan will not be able to cope with the volume of traffic.

"If so, for a period of four-plus months and with further disruption throughout the pretty much the entirety of 2023, we anticipate there will be a catastrophic impact on our businesses and residents."

The chamber is calling for their concerns to be addresses before the roadwork plans are officially signed off by the authorities.

After the horse has bolted? Who knows?  One thing is clear - Torbay needs to confront and confirm the 'tough decisions' needed for its future housing plans or this may just be the start of things to come..

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice