Jim Parker: Brixham - so important to Torbay and its Naturally Inspiring future

placeholder image

There are some weird goings on of late down in dear old Brixham... It would appear some of the natives are far from happy with their lot as part of the Torbay family. Now they want to leave the jurisdiction of Torbay Council and be governed by neighbouri

There are some weird goings on of late down in dear old Brixham...

It would appear some of the natives are far from happy with their lot as part of the Torbay family. Now they want to leave the jurisdiction of Torbay Council and be governed by neighbouring South Hams. It has even led to a parish poll.

It has been triggered by just 11 electors and will be staged like a usual election using polling stations on Thursday, April 13.

It will be overseen by Torbay Council chief executive and, in this instance, returning officer Anne-Marie Bond.

Voters will be asked to respond to two questions which were agreed at a recent Brixham parish meeting - put simply they are: Do you wish to leave the jurisdiction of Torbay Council? Do you wish Brixham to join the South Hams District?

I say staged like a 'usual election' but there are some differences. Ms Bond explains: "Unlike a usual election, there are no poll cards, nor any postal votes. Further, the result of the poll is not binding, it is purely an expression of views."

By the way, it will cost between £10,000 and £15,000 to run with Brixham Town Council picking up the tab!placeholder image
By the way, it will cost between £10,000 and £15,000 to run with Brixham Town Council picking up the tab!

Obviously somebody is trying to make a point somewhere. But it's a very expensive point and one that should be made with  caution - at least as far as former directly-elected mayor Nick Bye is concerned.

He says: "Perhaps the £15,000 cost of the Brixham parish poll might be better spent as the first donation to fund the repair of the Shoalstone open-air swimming pool.

"Whilst entirely a matter for Brixham residents to express a view on whether they would like to remain a part of Torbay or join South Hams, perhaps it would be sensible to consider - and he lists five considerations:

One: council tax bills in the South Hams are significantly higher than in Torquay and Paignton where for example a 'C' band property incurs a charge of £1,895 whereas in Dartmouth it's £2,098, Kingsbridge £2,014, Ivybridge £2,061 and Totnes even higher at £2,118. Admittedly, council taxpayers in Brixham already pay more than Torquay and Paignton to cover the cost of their town council, but would they want to pay more again?

Two: the lion's share of money paid by council taxpayers in the South Hams goes to Devon County Council who provide 'upper tier' services for Children and Adults. At present Devon County Council's children's services are judged 'inadequate' by Ofsted (Torbay's were most recently judged 'good') so it is highly unlikely consent would be given for any reorganisation.

Three: South Hams have been struggling with their bin collections for some time and made regional news headlines on this topic and for all the wrong reasons in 2021 and last year. Would they want to take on the bin rounds in Brixham which around the harbour, town centre and St Mary's must be amongst the most awkward to service?

Four: On The Buses! Torbay Council generously pays between three and four million pounds each year through the concessionary bus scheme to cover the cost of bus fares for mostly older people (there is no longer a dedicated government grant for this) and subsidises a number of local bus routes, including some in Brixham. How can we be confident Devon County or South Hams, would continue with all this?

Five: who would handle tourism promotion and destination management? Our English Riviera BID Company currently covers Brixham and its chief executive Carolyn Custerson has a real passion for Brixham. Is there a South Hams Tourism Board? If so, I have never heard of it."

Then Mr Bye turns to Berry Head saying: "Then what about Berry Head, currently managed by Torbay Coast and Countryside Trust, an organisation which we all take for granted but probably unique in this part of the world.

"Would South Hams be happy to pay a management fee or would it prefer to manage the site itself and perhaps charge an entry fee or increase parking charges?"

The ex-mayor is well aware of well-aired claims that Brixham is always left behind 'big brothers' in Torquay and Paignton, but he says: "Where is all the evidence of Brixham being 'the poor relation' in the Bay?

"In my personal view, Brixham is one of the most-improved towns in Devon and the beneficiary of the most successful regeneration project in recent years, the new fish quay, employment spaces and restaurant which has led to a renaissance of the fishing industry.

"Yours truly brokered the deal with millions of Torbay Council, DEFRA and European Union money going into this project. Also in my term of office we had the Seachange project with extension of the Guardhouse Cafe and much more at Berry Head; £250,000 of Torbay Council money went into the rebuild of the Admiral Swimming Pool; the Old Market House project (remember the fuss about that!) increased footfall around the harbour; new homes were built, including social rented homes for local people and Astra Zenneca completed their new buildings at Freshwater Cove. These buildings are now in the ownership of Plymouth University and the base for numerous marine based businesses."

He adds: "Of course, I understand the disenchantment with local councils, planning decisions which go the wrong way, the state of our roads, town centres and much else. There are, doubtless, residents in Wellswood, St Marychurch and Shiphay who must wonder what they get for all their council tax money and would love to opt out. But my advice would be to be careful what you wish for.

"The grass might be greener in the South Hams but what about the bills, the 'buses, the bins and all the rest?"

Well, I think we all know where Mr Bye stands on this - as always never shy when it comes to expressing an opinion.

For me, it all comes at a time when we are trying to get Brixham to join the Torbay party not leave it - and we have had some success.

Brixham has a huge part to play in the new Torbay Story initiative with its independent creativity, food and fishing key 'USPs' as we sell and promote the Bay.

We are in the middle of setting up groups/organisations/boards at a town level to give the community and town leaders a united voice to tell strategic leaders want they need for the 21st century.

With a group of stake-holders already formed and united in the battle over the Windy Corner roadworks, Brixham are already three quarters of the way there and keen to progress.

It is the only way Brixham will ever get anywhere near a new town centre, bigger fish quay and more parking.

If the 'Brixham 11' intend to give some a rap on the knuckles, then good luck - but they will know better than most that time is not on their side. It is running out.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice