Jim Parker and politics today: Six PMs, musical chairs and a touch of Spock and Henry the Eighth


A tongue-in-cheek look at politics nationally and locally
Talk about a Banana Republic, our politicians have gone bananas!
Politics nationally can be intriguing sometimes especially when you see people playing games in a bid to manoeuvre towards power. By the way, I have no time for politics at a local level and believe there is be no need or place to play silly political games in that environment and that covers the cloth of all political parties and colours as I know some will jump quickly on the Jim’s ‘Tory Weekly’ wagon claims again!
I have visited Parliament several times and it has always struck me as an institution steeped in history and living in the past. I am sure it still serves Double Diamond in the bars and you feel as if Henry the Eighth is about to stick his head around the corner at any time to say hello.
Parliament, the Commons and even more so the Lords, appear to be in a bubble all of their own and many of the people in that bubble rarely step outside and have little experience of real, everyday life.
Then you realise these people run your, our lives!
Some would say they couldn’t run a you-know-what in a brewery as we head towards our seventh Prime Minister in 10 years. Wow!
The end for PM Sir Keir Starmer was as predictable as night follows day. In fact, how he hung on for so long is beyond me. Once you lose the changing room you’ve lost the plot and the only thing left in his was the first aid box.
Likewise it would hardly be a shock or earth shattering if Andy Burnham was to be spotted at the local locksmith getting a set of keys cut for Number 10. That political manoeuvring for power began many months ago.
There was lots of reaction to the end for Sir Kier from across the local political spectrum.
The out-going PM was quite emotional as he revealed his resignation intentions in Downing Street with his wife looking on.
It is something Torbay Liberal Democrat MP Steve Darling commented on, saying the departing Prime Minister could have connected better with the voting public if he had shown more emotion.
“Sometimes we need more of Captain Kirk than of Spock in politics,” he said.
Leading Exeter Labour councillor and council leader Phil Bialyk said Sir Keir had not always received the best advice over issues such as the winter fuel allowance.
Then he hit the nail on the head for me when he said: “We need to stop telling people what we think is good for them.”
Dead right, Phil - the government should be creating growth and jobs, improving living standards and making sure we can defend ourselves and not telling me what I should be eating or drinking or forcing me to have my eyes tested.
Glowing praise came from Labour heartlands, such as Plymouth, where the city council leader, Tudor Evans, credited Sir Keir with “saving the Labour party”.
What is somewhat contrasting is that while all these shenanigans are being played out nationally, local authorities like Torbay face an uncertain future as the very same government looking for a new leader and Prime Minister forges ahead with Local Government Reorganisation and telling the likes of Torbay what to do.
Don’t get me wrong, the Bay has done well in the past few months from the central government including the awarding of £40million Pride in Place funding for Torquay and parts of Paignton aimed at improving our town centres and the lives of people living in some of our most deprived communities.
But when it comes to LGR, councils such as Torbay may have to deal with its third minister in just a couple of years at the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government.
The national musical chairs come at a crucial time in LGR.
An announcement on how local government may look going forward may just be weeks and conversations with Westminster were taking place only this week.
Torbay deputy leader Chris Lewis was due on a call with other council leaders and officials in the past few days.
He says: “We could be dealing with the third local government minister in a couple of years due to the comings and goings in leadership at national level.
“It is a difficult time with potentially three ministers in two years and seven Prime Ministers in 10:years.”
Clr Lewis’s family is steeped in history. His father, Sir Kenneth Lewis was a Conservative politician and former RAF officer who was MP for Rutland for 28 years
Cllr Lewis first stood as a councillor in Croydon in 1978 and has been a councillor in Torbay for 20 years, surviving (for the want of a better word) five elections in 2007, 2011, 2015, 2019 and 2023. Only fellow councillors Nicole Amil and current Tory group leader Dave Thomas have been on the same journey and are still on it
He says of the current national situation: “To be honest it’s sad that we’ve been through so many Prime Ministers. In our generation you had a Prime Minister and they stayed. You did not get rebellions from back benchers.
“In my era there was Margaret Thatcher for 10 years and Tony Blair for 10 years
“Now you get elected with an overwhelming majority and are given a mandate only for 400 MPs from your own party to kick you out.”
He accepts the two main parties were as much to blame as each other including dear old Boris Johnson although he believes: “There are reasons why Boris went with Covid and being a bad boy.”
But he added: “Normally if you have a majority like that like Margaret Thatcher and Tony Blair had you survived 10 years even though you made some difficult decisions
“Now you get MPs saying ‘oh, we don’t like him’ It makes a mockery of our country.
“There won’t be a general election. That would be like turkeys voting for Christmas.”
On the LGR front back in the Bay, there are several scenarios being considered, including Plymouth, Exeter and Torbay as unitary authorities but with the Bay taking in some parts of the South Hams and Teignbridge.
The shake-up could see the current cohort of councillors stay in post for another year from next May but there would be an election for a shadow council and councillors who could make over-riding decisions.
Former Torbay MP Kevin Foster has thrown the possibility of an elected mayor into the pot.
He says: “Andy Burnham needs to set out his policies and plan to sort the public finances, he can’t govern simply through social media vibes. One thing we do know is the chances of us having an elected mayor have gone up significantly given Andy Burnham’s own enthusiasm for the role.”
Cllr Lewis is clear on what the Bay wants but you wouldn’t bet your house on it being the chosen outcome.
Cllr Lewis says: “We are fighting to stay as we are. The only other local authority to stay as it is so far is the Isle of Wight. Perhaps we could do with water on the other side of us.”
He added: “We have a good record. Adult services are good. Children’s services are good. Regeneration is good. We tick all the boxes going forward
“We do not want disruption and to be taken off track. If we have another four years these things will be delivered
“With LGR you could get councillors who do not know Torbay. That is a big fear.
"We have councillors until May next year. Then we will have councillors from outside of the Bay who do not know the past and what major projects are going forward.
"That's the great fear. It could delay all the major projects we are going to do.
"The shadow council will have the powers to veto any capital projects.
"My view is leave Torbay alone. Torbay over the last three-and-a-half years has done a good job.
"We do not want interference from the government. We were elected three years ago to deliver and that is what we are going to do.
"We do not want the national government telling us what to do."
Fingers crossed for a positive outcome for the English Riviera. Trouble is who knows what may happen next
I’m voting for Henry the Eighth!