Green light for Teignmouth health centre - but campaign to save town's hospital goes on


By Guy Henderson and Ollie Heptinstall, local democracy reporters Teignmouth’s controversial new health and wellbeing centre has been given a unanimous thumbs-up from planners. Members of the Teignbridge planning committee gave the new centre the go-ahe
By Guy Henderson and Ollie Heptinstall, local democracy reporters
Teignmouth’s controversial new health and wellbeing centre has been given a unanimous thumbs-up from planners.
Members of the Teignbridge planning committee gave the new centre the go-ahead after a lengthy debate at their meeting yesterday (Tuesday, June 13).
The new £11million facility in Brunswick Street will bring GP services, healthcare and voluntary sector services under one roof, but the application has been controversial in Teignmouth, with local protesters mounting a furious campaign against the existing hospital’s closure.
Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust claims the community’s needs will be better served by the new complex.
But objector Gerald Penny told the meeting: “I have been totally opposed to this development since it was first mooted. This was an afterthought when there were such vociferous objections to the closure of Teignmouth Hospital.”
Mr Penny said there would not be enough parking and not enough access to public transport. “If it weren’t so serious I think this would be a joke,” he said.
The trust, however, says the building will provide an effective hub for around 150 people to deliver GP and community services. It will safeguard access to primary care.
The council already owns the land, where existing buildings will be demolished to make way for the new centre. The planned three-storey centre will include consulting rooms, treatment areas, offices and a ‘pandemic suite’.
A report to the planning meeting said the new centre would bring ‘significant benefits’ for the town, although objectors say the proposed building is too big and that valuable town centre parking spaces will be lost.
The town’s community hospital in Mill Lane is due to close, with its services moving to Dawlish Hospital and the new health centre.


Meanwhile, more evidence will be gathered before Devon county councillors decide whether to refer Teignmouth Hospital’s planned closure to the Health Secretary again.
Devon’s health scrutiny committee, when it also met yesterday, agreed to continue gathering evidence for a potential second review by the government after Cllr Martin Wrigley admitted: “We don’t have all of the evidence.”
The committee will now put a number of questions to the NHS to help it come to a decision in September on another referral, with Cllr Wrigley adding: “We need to build a sufficient evidence pack to be able to refer the decision... back to the Secretary of State.
“And the basis that we can do that upon is it’s not in the long-term interests of the health service in the area, and that is what we’re looking into.”
He added: “I think we have a good start on this process but it is taking longer than I would have hoped, but I think we will get there in the end.”
The scrutiny meeting heard from local campaigner Geralyn Arthurs, who urged the committee to review the hospital closure decision. “The rehabilitation beds should never have been removed from our hospital, especially as Teignmouth has no nursing homes.”
She quoted the area’s MP Anne Marie Morris, who last year said: “I remain very concerned that this decision is not in the best interests of Teignmouth residents.”
Ms Arthurs said: “Please look after the vulnerable, frail and elderly who need our hospital and all the health service’s provision.”
Jo Turl, NHS Devon’s director of out-of-hospital commissioning, told the committee that full funding has been secured for the new health and wellbeing centre in the town but confirmed it doesn’t rely on the hospital closing.
She added the NHS would respond to any written questions submitted by the committee and that a group, chaired independently by Healthwatch, will begin meeting in July to discuss the hospital site’s future.
When the committee agreed to look into a second referral in March, an NHS spokesperson said: “The way we provide care in the Teignmouth and Dawlish area is very successful and receives very positive feedback from patients and carers.
“Our model of providing care gives us more capacity than a rehabilitation ward would – when we consulted with local people in 2020, we estimated that we could treat four times as many people in their own homes as we could in a rehabilitation ward in Teignmouth Hospital with the same investment.”