Dr Peter Moore: Taxing anyone on the basis they are unwell cannot be right

placeholder image

I am cautious of campaigns. The latest opposes any increase to the age older people pay for their prescriptions. In 2021, the Government ran a consultation asking whether the upper age for free prescriptions should be increased from 60 to the state pensi

I am cautious of campaigns. The latest opposes any increase to the age older people pay for their prescriptions.

In 2021, the Government ran a consultation asking whether the upper age for free prescriptions should be increased from 60 to the state pension age.

There has been no government response. I can see why. It is a political poisoned chalice. Why should yet more older people pay for their prescriptions?

In a good politician’s response, I am not in favour of increasing the age when people pay but I will not sign any petition. It is like protesting about the comfort of the deck chairs on the Titanic.

The whole system is fundamentally wrong. To make the system even less fair only the English pay. The Welsh, Northern Irish and Scots do not. The prescription charge is an NHS tax. It does not directly pay for the medicines on the prescription.

There is a long list of people who do not pay for their prescriptions. This includes anyone over 60, any child under 16, pregnant, on a war pension or anyone suffering from a list of medical conditions. It also includes some people on benefits such as income support but not all benefits.

Once someone qualifies for exemption from this tax, it applies to all prescribed medication. I could get free paracetamol (I don’t) as I am over 60. Currently, according to a government answer in parliament in 2019, 89 per cent of NHS prescriptions are dispensed free of charge.

But there are people with very little money who do not fit into any of these boxes.

For the unlucky 11 per cent who pay, each item costs £9.35. Some people are on three or four items costing nearly £40 a time. It is possible to get a season ticket for a year costing £108.10 but the patient still needs to find the cash. During a cost-of- living crisis this can be difficult.

Even when I was working, patients asked me which was the least important drug as they could not afford everything. The answer, of course, was that they were all important otherwise I would not have prescribed them.

The list of medical exemptions has not changed since 1968. The logic then was that no-one who is on long-term medication would pay which included people with, for example, an under-active thyroid gland, diabetes, or epilepsy.

The problem is that there are now a huge number of diseases which could not be treated in 1968 but now have an excellent outlook with long-term medication.

In 1968, anyone with angina was given very cheap tablets to put under the tongue when they developed pain. There was very little effective treatment for blood pressure. Asthma inhalers were in their infancy.

Now people with angina may receive a stent and need lifelong medication such as statins. Blood pressure is treated effectively and there are several different asthma inhalers.

The Royal Pharmaceutical Society, which represents pharmacists including high street chemists, have started a campaign to change the system. As they point out: “The false economy of tax raising from the sick ignores the impact on people’s health, hospital admissions and ability to remain at work.”

Taxing anyone on the basis that they are unwell and need medication cannot be right. Also, the exemptions for this tax does not take into account the ability to pay except in a few specified cases.

The problem is that, according to Government figures, in 2017-18 it raised £576 million. The 11 per cent who pay believe, wrongly, that they are paying for their medication and do not realise it is a tax.

It would be fairer if everyone paid £1 but starting to charge the elderly and sick who do not currently pay would be political suicide. Ideally, we need an all-party group to devise a fair tax for the whole of the UK but, as Edmund Burke almost said “to tax and to please... is not given to men” although today he would include women.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice