Dr Peter Moore: Some nursery rhymes are better forgotten

placeholder image

How many people remember the line ‘are you sitting comfortably? Then we’ll begin’? I hope everyone reading this column is sitting comfortably although anyone old enough to remember these lines probably finds sitting more comfortable than getting up. Now

How many people remember the line ‘are you sitting comfortably? Then we’ll begin’?

I hope everyone reading this column is sitting comfortably although anyone old enough to remember these lines probably finds sitting more comfortable than getting up.

Now Listen with Mother would have to be Listen with Parent but even Listen with Parent is in the past.

A recent survey of 2,000 parents aged between 26 and 41 found that almost half did not know some of the most traditional nursey rhymes such as ‘Rock a Bye Baby’ or ‘Humpty Dumpty’.

They may even believe that ‘Rock a Bye Baby’ is rock music. Anyway, telling a baby that their cradle might fall out of a tree is hardly reassuring.

Only half could sing ‘Row, Row, Row Your Boat’. Those who know ‘Baa Baa Black Sheep’ think it is a bit racist.

Some parents send their children to sleep with Kanye West or even the Rolling Stones, who are old enough to remember Listen with Mother.

Traditional nursery rhymes have a wonderful rhythm but often completely meaningless words.

No-one knows which Grand old Duke of York marched his men to the top of the hill and down again but it is best to avoid songs about the current Duke of York.

Little Jack Horner was a dodgy character in Henry VIII’s time who stole the deeds to a monastery. The song was probably a 16th century version of Have I got News for You.

We have no idea who Humpty Dumpty was, why he sat on a wall and why the King’s men were so unsuccessful. At least Lewis Carroll gave him one of my favourite quotes in Alice through the Looking Glass: ‘When I use a word it means just what I choose it to mean – neither more nor less’, a quote which applies to most politicians today.

‘Ring a Ring a Roses’ has been around in various forms since at least the 18th century but, despite the rumours, there is no evidence that it refers to the plague, which I find reassuring.

But the young children’s song which I find most irritating is ‘Miss Polly had a Dolly’.

She immediately calls for the doctor to come quick, quick, quick. Why not NHS 111?

The doctor came with his bag and his hat. I do not think dolly needs a visit. She can come up to the surgery. And why ‘his bag’ and not ‘her bag’?

The doctor then tells Miss Polly, or should she be Ms Polly, to put the dolly straight to bed. Bed rest rarely helps and risks a deep venous thrombosis.

He then wrote on a paper for a pill, pill pill. It must be paper as prescription pad or even FP10 does not have the right meter.

But why give a prescription? Most childhood illnesses get better with paracetamol. If it is a virus she does not need antibiotics.

The most telling part of the song is ‘I’ll be back in the morning with my bill, bill bill’. This explains why the doctor did an unnecessary visit. Her dolly would not have received the same treatment on the NHS.

Some nursery rhymes are better forgotten.

As a child I remember counting, ‘Eeny Meany Miny Moe’. Today, I am embarrassed by the next, appalling line which I will not quote.

Research from Toronto found that lullabies can help children’s cognitive development, increases the child’s attention span and shows positive emotion.

The good news is that 80 per cent of millennial parents ensure that bedtime is a positive relaxing time. A third use a ‘soother’ playing relaxing noises.

Provided young children get time with their parents when going to bed, does it matter whether they sing ‘London Bridge is Falling Down’ or George Ezra? Teaching young children about shotguns could be inappropriate but then singing about collapsing bridges is also scary.

If anyone really wants to send their children to sleep, I suggest reading them my column at night.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice