Dr Peter Moore: Should all medical information always be private?

placeholder image

Looking back on the tragic case of Nicola Bulley whose body was found in the River Wyre, were the police justified when they told the public about her alcohol problems and difficulties with the menopause? Should all medical information always be private?

Looking back on the tragic case of Nicola Bulley whose body was found in the River Wyre, were the police justified when they told the public about her alcohol problems and difficulties with the menopause?

Should all medical information always be private?

Even for doctors, confidentiality is not absolute. There are situations when doctors are not only allowed to breach confidentiality but it is a legal obligation.

If a doctor knows an epileptic is having fits but continues to drive, they must first of all point out to the patient that they are breaking the law and risking others. If the patient continues to drive the doctor must tell the authorities at the DVLA.

Any responsibility to the patient is outweighed by the responsibility to the public preventing the driver having a fit at the wheel putting others at risk.

If a GP found out that a patient was a known paedophile and working with children or was told in confidence that a patient was planning a terrorist act, the doctor must tell the authorities.

I had a case of a local heroin addict who murdered another addict and fled. The police asked me whether he was on any prescribed medication. Would he try to approach a doctor elsewhere for a prescription?

I took legal advice and was told that as he was an on-going danger to the public I should tell a named senior police officer and record the conversation in the notes. I told the duty inspector only to find that he had already been arrested.

I cannot comment on the police operation to find Nicola Bulley as my only knowledge of the case comes from the press although a complete lack of knowledge and experience did not stop social media going into overdrive. Even some journalists speculated.

The whole case demonstrates two observations, the Dunning Kruger effect and Occombe’s razor, which has nothing to do with Occombe Farm.

The Dunning Kurger effect states that when we know nothing about a subject we think we are an expert. As we gain more understanding we can see our acres of ignorance. Real experts are far more cautious than armchair experts.

When Nicola disappeared social media was full of ignorant speculation, some of it quite offensive. People who have learnt all their detective skills from real crime books or Silent Witness think they are more expert than 'Mr Plod' the policeman.

Not only was my brother a detective inspector but I have worked with detectives as a police surgeon. I have seen enough of their incredible expertise to understand that there is a whole field about which I am ignorant.

Occombe’s razor states that when there are many possibilities it is the most obvious and simple which is the most likely. This flies in the face of most TV detectives. A who-done-it when the obvious killer did it would be short and bad TV.

When someone goes missing close to a fast-flowing river, the possibility of falling in must be the most likely option. Of course, the police must always keep an open mind for other possibilities but look at the obvious first. All along the police worked on the hypothesis that she fell in and, sadly, were proved right.

Without knowing the inside story I have no idea whether releasing the information about her alcohol problem and perimenopause was appropriate.

In my practice we sometimes had cases when social services or the NHS were strongly criticised when I knew that their actions were justified. The problem was that the public can make accusations against professionals when the professionals cannot put the record straight without breaching confidentiality.

Putting the record straight cannot always be justified by public interest.

After her body was found ITV and Sky news approached her family. This was appalling and it is now being investigated. The police investigation and their release of confidential information is also under investigation. Hopefully, both can learn from this tragedy.

It is a pity that no-one is investigating the offensive online keyboard warriors.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice