Dr Peter Moore: Primary care proposals risk destroy essence of general practice

placeholder image

When I was a student I sat in on an amazing GP in the East End of London. He had been there for years and knew his patients well. When one man came in with a backache he listened carefully, carried out a thorough examination, arranged blood tests and an

When I was a student I sat in on an amazing GP in the East End of London. He had been there for years and knew his patients well.

When one man came in with a backache he listened carefully, carried out a thorough examination, arranged blood tests and an X ray. There were no scans available in the early 1970s. This seemed remarkable for 'ordinary backache' but afterwards he explained what was happening.

“I’ve known him for years. It’s not like him to come here for backache and he did not look well. When I examined him I thought he might have a prostate cancer which has spread to his spine.”

The following week he told me that the cancer had been confirmed and the patient was now in hospital.

This taught me an important lesson which stayed throughout my career. In my hospital training I had learnt how to take a history, make an examination and arrange tests but I realised that general practice offers far more. A GP does not have 10 minutes with the patient but 30 years in 10-minute slots.

When GPs see a patient they watch carefully how they walk into the room, how they give a history, watch for non-verbal clues and tone of voice. Does their speech and demeanour match their words? Are they looking at the floor while muttering “I’m OK”? Knowing the patient and family, does this fit in with their normal behaviour? If someone who rarely sees the GP comes in with a minor illness it may mean that something is else going on.

Sadly, this does not fit in with the latest proposal to pluck doctors from hospital to work in general practice. Hospital doctors with no general practice training cannot possibly understand the nuances of the job any more than we could just pluck doctors from general practice and ask them to work as a consultant cardiologist or surgeon.

This is not helped by some consultants with no experience or understanding of general practice supporting the move.

General practice is a specialised job which requires a further five years of training and an exam.

It is also argued that GPs should not be seeing patients with minor problems who are 'wasting their time'. I often wonder what would happen today with our man with a backache. Would he just be triaged and given painkillers or put on a long waiting list for physiotherapy?

There are also plans to improve the phone system to avoid the 8am rush. Getting an appointment at some surgeries is like getting tickets for Glastonbury, hanging on the phone hoping you’re lucky.

Now the phone system will be able to take multiple calls and direct people to other services. There may even be better hold music.

Under the proposals earache, sore throat, urine infections in women, sinusitis, shingles and infected insect bites can all be dealt with by a trained pharmacist who can also prescribe the contraceptive pill and check blood pressure.

Some of these ideas are helpful but, even here, I have reservations. A sore throat can be an excuse to come in. A good GP will be able to pick out the non-verbal clues and ask themselves why have they come with a sore throat. Do they have the false idea they need antibiotics or is there something else? Are they terrified because a friend or relative has throat cancer or maybe it is anxiety reflecting other problems.

The real problem with general practice is that there are not enough GPs. This is not only about training enough, but also about keeping them when they can earn far more and have a better lifestyle in Australia. Can we make the job work better for doctors with a family and reduce the pressure and bureaucracy?

It may just be that I am a dinosaur, an old man reminiscing 'it was better in my day'. There are major problems in primary care but we must not destroy the essence of general practice when trying to fix the problem.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice