Dr Peter Moore: Prescriptions are thanks to Torquay doctor's campaign against 'secret poisoning'

placeholder image

I don’t think I’ll ever change the law and save lives. Beavering away in the surgery over the years I did not look up to see the bigger picture. But one of my predecessors in Torquay did influence parliament and improve the law. Dr Toogood sounds like

I don’t think I’ll ever change the law and save lives.

Beavering away in the surgery over the years I did not look up to see the bigger picture.

But one of my predecessors in Torquay did influence parliament and improve the law.

Dr Toogood sounds like a character from the Mr Men books like Dr Makeyouwell from Mr Bump. In fact, he was a doctor in Torquay.

In 1849, he wrote to Dr Charles Hastings, the president of the Council of the Provincial and Surgical Association, the body which would later be renamed the BMA.

His letter was headed ‘On the crime of secret poisoning’ which would have made a good title for the other famous Torquay resident, Agatha Christie.

Just up the M5 in Taunton a woman called Sarah Freeman had been tried and hanged for murder. Not content with one murder she had poisoned her husband, mother, child and brother.

Bridgwater Town Council had sent a letter to Sir Robert Peel suggesting that the sale of poisons should be restricted.

Dr Toogood was more dramatic in his phraseology saying that several family members were ‘swept away’.

Arsenic, he pointed out, was available at every druggist and many country shops but had become the commonest poison used in murder.

It had no taste, colour or smell and so could easily be added to food without the victim suspecting.

The ‘secret poisoning’ was often not detected which begs the question of how anyone knew it was a problem.

He proposed a ‘check (on) the indiscriminate sale of poisons to illiterate persons, and especially of arsenic’. He must have assumed that anyone who could read and write could not possibly be a murderer.

Anyone selling arsenic, he suggested, should be licenced and keep a record book. Customers buying arsenic also needed to bring a witness and both should sign for it.

He was impressed by Austria, where no-one was allowed to sell medicines of any description without a medical education and a satisfactory licence and it was only the apothecary who could dispense a physician or surgeon’s prescription.

All poisons had to be locked away and medicines could only be made up by the head to the establishment. Just like today there was a list of ‘prescription only’ medicines.

And there, apothecaries were more strictly controlled. According to Dr Toogood, they could not ‘prescribe even the most simple remedies, nor perform the most insignificant surgical operations; nay, more, he cannot sell a dose of physic without the written order of the physician or surgeon who is recognized by the university of his country’.

It also seems there was also more control on the qualifications of physicians and surgeons than in Britain.

In 1856, there were 10,220 men in the medical directory but only four per cent had a medical degree. And 94 per cent of British physicians and surgeons were not recognised by any university. There were, of course, no women.

The Austrian rules, Dr Toogood pointed out, protected ‘against quacks, mountebanks, patent medicines’.

In the England, where there was a free market, ‘modest females are insulted by having indecent hand-bills thrust upon them in the open streets’.

I do not know whether the letter from my Torquay colleague helped but two years later, in 1851 the Arsenic Act was passed. This prohibited the sale of arsenic to anyone the druggist did not know. There was a fine of £20.

It did not pass smoothly as the House of Lords unsuccessfully tried to amend the Act to ban any woman from buying arsenic.

Were they worried that their wives might be trying to poison them?

So whenever you are given a doctor’s prescription which can only be dispensed by a chemist, you can thank a Torquay doctor from 1849, although he did not foresee ordering prescriptions on line from an app.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice