Dr Peter Moore: Paying for GP appointments


As we enter 2023, the NHS is in crisis. There is no simple solution, the NHS is a highly complex organisation, but that has not stopped every armchair expert from having all the answers. There is one idea doing the rounds which sounds logical but has not
As we enter 2023, the NHS is in crisis. There is no simple solution, the NHS is a highly complex organisation, but that has not stopped every armchair expert from having all the answers.
There is one idea doing the rounds which sounds logical but has not been thought through, should we charge patients to see a GP?
Would this take pressure off GPs and help the cash strapped NHS? It might even stop the 'time wasters'.
Putting aside the politics of 'free at the point of need', should everyone pay? Presumably the very poor, elderly and seriously ill would be exempt. So how do we decide who pays?
There is a precedent, prescription charges. Although most people would pay for their prescriptions, over 80 per cent of prescriptions actually dispensed are free. Children, the poor, the elderly and the long-term sick do not pay, the same people who are most likely to need a prescription.
If the same criteria were used to see a GP, over 80 per cent would not pay.
There will always be people on the borderline, people who have to pay but find it difficult. I remember a patient with asthma who was not entitled to free prescriptions asking me which was a least important inhaler as he could not afford them all. Of course, they were all important.
Another option would be to charge higher rate taxpayers but only 16 per cent of people pay the higher rate of tax. And again not many of the long-term sick and elderly are higher rate tax payers.
The NHS is also putting out adverts asking people to see their GP for a series of symptoms which could be a cancer. People with cancer do much better if diagnosed early. Do we really want to give people another reason 'not to bother the GP'?
GPs only occasionally collect money for such things as immunisations for foreign holidays. Charging some patients for each consultation would add a new layer of bureaucracy. GP practices have enough forms to fill in already.
And what would happen if a seriously ill person is rushed to the surgery, the GP carries out emergency treatment and admits the patient straight to hospital? Will the patient get a bill? What happens to anyone who refuses to pay? Will we see GPs or the NHS taking patients to court?
Many people need a regular review but will the GP have to say to a middle-aged man with high blood pressure 'can you afford to come back to have your blood pressure checked?'.
If a consultation with the GP costs money, would people go to the free A&E department? A&E departments are busy enough. If 111 gave patients the option of the GP or A&E, it is obvious which they would choose. If A&E departments then charged for 'GP type' cases how on earth does anyone decide on the borderline cases?
One of the problems with healthcare is that it does not fit in well with a market economy. It is the worst off, the poor, the elderly and the long-term sick who need the most care and they have the least money. The people comfortably off who would not mind paying for the GP are less likely to need a GP.
There are countries which charge for GP appointments but most of those countries have an insurance-based system. Patients claim the money back from their insurance company. Although I would not favour an insurance-based system this is a legitimate argument, and it works well in many countries throughout the world.
Are those suggesting we should charge for GP appointments really saying they would like an insurance-based system instead of the NHS? Or do they want a system where most people use a private health insurance leaving the NHS as a safety net for the poor?
I don’t agree but I respect their opinion but would ask them to be honest.
The NHS is in crisis and we need new innovative ideas but asking people to pay for GP appointments will not solve the problem. It could make it worse.