Dr Peter Moore: Nuance of history - why good teachers matter

placeholder image

A teacher told me about a group of students who were asked: “What is your favourite subject?” After everyone gave their answer, they were asked why. Almost all of them replied it was because they had a brilliant teacher. I was lucky enough to have a bri

A teacher told me about a group of students who were asked: “What is your favourite subject?”

After everyone gave their answer, they were asked why. Almost all of them replied it was because they had a brilliant teacher.

I was lucky enough to have a brilliant history teacher and, 60 years later, I am still a rather boring history geek. But does history matter? Who cares how many wives Henry VIII had or whether Oliver Cromwell banned Christmas?

I am not in touch with history teaching today but slightly worried about some of the results.

My impression, which may be wrong, is that history is seen as goodies and baddies. It is easy to see why Hitler and the Nazis were baddies but the British Empire was all bad? As our evil ancestors practised slavery, we must remove the names and pull down statues of anyone who might have had some connection with slavery, however tenuous.

What makes history fascinating is that the whole subject is far more nuanced.

Of course, the slave trade was evil and no-one could condone grabbing people from Africa, transporting them across the Atlantic in appalling conditions and selling them into slavery but we need to look wider than just the slave trade.

Manchester was nick named 'cottonopolis' as it became the world centre for manufacturing cotton fabric. But where was the cotton imported from?

Cotton, sugar and tobacco were all produced using slave labour. At the same time, the workers in Manchester factories were also abused including young children.

But this was all seen as part of a 'natural hierarchy'. A verse in 'All Things Bright and Beautiful' which is no longer sung is:

The rich man in his castle,

The poor man at his gate,

God made them high and lowly,

And ordered their estate.

Mrs C F Alexander, who wrote the hymn, was not interested in levelling up.

Equally, teaching about which side was morally right in the Second World War is straightforward but even here there are some fascinating questions.

How was a whole nation taken over by a regime which, in hindsight, was obviously evil? Before we assume there was something different about the Germans, we need to look at British middle class in the 1930s.

Eugenics, the belief that some races are inherently superior to others, was popular. It was founded in Britain by Charles Darwin’s cousin, Sir Francis Galton, and supported by the famous economist John Maynard Keynes, Winston Churchill and many people in the Church of England.

In the archives of Torquay Medical Society, there is a debate on family planning when a local doctor supports family planning as it is 'utter folly' to allow inferior races and people to breed.

In fairness many of these distinguished people changed their view that they saw the dreadful consequences of this philosophy in the Nazi death camps.

The whole idea of Empire is now seen as fundamentally misguided. Today, the idea that the British sailed into other countries and put up the Union flag is wrong. Our ancestors exploited other lands. But we need to understand the zeitgeist at the time.

I have a rather embarrassing Victorian tablecloth. In the centre is says 'the civilisation of Fiji'. The sides start with 'before civilisation' and a picture of the natives running around chased by a sea monster. We then get 'dawn of civilisation' with Britannia arriving followed by 'advance of civilisation' with the locals looking at clothes and finally 'the glorious result of civilisation' with the black locals walking around as Victorian ladies and gentlemen. They are even taking off their top hats and bowing to ladies.

This is clearly racist and would not be accepted today but it shows that the ultimate aim was not to wipe out the locals but to convert them to our way of life.

And who were the goodies in the English Civil War? In a typically British way central London has statues of both Charles I and Oliver Cromwell. If we take sides which statue should be torn down?

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice