Dr Peter Moore: No-one is responsible for their ancestors


A friend told me an elderly relative took him aside and, almost in a whisper, said: “As you’re the oldest in your generation, I need to tell you a family secret which must not get out.” He wondered what was so terrible. Were they a part of an internation
A friend told me an elderly relative took him aside and, almost in a whisper, said: “As you’re the oldest in your generation, I need to tell you a family secret which must not get out.”
He wondered what was so terrible. Were they a part of an international criminal gang or sex traffickers?
“It was our ancestor who rowed Guy Fawkes across the Thames before he tried to blow up the Houses of Parliament in 1605.”
He tried to keep a straight face. This may have been a serious risk to the family if it became public knowledge in 1606 but today it might not be such a risk.
Nobody will send them to the Tower of London to be tortured and beheaded. They could even admit to being Catholics.
Now Benedict Cumberbatch may be sued by the Barbados Government because his seventh great grandfather, Joshua Cumberbatch, owned a plantation on the island where he kept 250 slaves.
And Barbados is chasing the Tory MP Richard Drax, who inherited a sugar plantation which was established in the 1620s and once used slave labour.
The BBC journalist Laura Trevelyan has donated £100,000 to Grenada where her ancestor owned at sugar plantation and now the Irish are chasing her because another ancestor was horrible in the famine of the 1840s.
Did any of my ancestors commit atrocities? During the lockdown, I started to look at my family tree.
My three times great grandfather was the Archbishop of Dublin, Richard Whatley. He was also the three times great grandfather of 'Lewis', Kevin Whatley, and so we are extremely distant cousins along with hundreds of others.
Archbishop Whatley was described as Ireland's strangest archbishop, but he also opposed slavery and supported the Irish people during the potato famine.
When the Irish Americans tell us they hate Britain because of the way their ancestors were treated, I can smile and say 'not mine'.
I can also be pompous when us Brits are criticised for the slave trade. Less impressive was the fact that he used to make terrible puns and so I may have inherited a bad pun gene.
Most of my ancestors seemed to be clergymen, so am I safe from scandal? My great great grandfather was the vicar of Shaldon, the Rev Rufus Hutton.
I then found a newspaper cutting from 1854 from Teignmouth Magistrates' Court. He was charged with severely assaulting a child named Morley 'between six and seven years old', the son of a shipwright.
The child’s left arm, shoulder and back 'exhibited signs of a severe punishment'. The child, 'a scholar at Shaldon Primary School', kicked the governess in the shins 'in return for a blow she had struck him on the head'.
Rev Hutton took 11 days to decide the punishment and then inflicted the injuries with a stick. He was fined £5 and told that if he did not pay immediately, he would go to jail for two months.
When we consider that in Victorian times punishment with a cane or birch was considered normal and that a vicar would have been highly respected the injuries must have been serious.
I am hoping that there is no-one in Shaldon called Morley who is planning to sue me.
Sadly, in 1876, he was admitted to Wonford Lunatic Asylum, where he died. I cannot find any more details but it looks as though his life ended in tragedy.
I cannot feel guilty about my great great grandfather, the vicar of Shaldon who behaved appallingly. He may have had mental health issues. I’m not sure the governess was much better hitting a young child around the head.
But if I deny any guilt from Rev Hutton I cannot take any credit for the archbishop, who came from another side of the family.
Genealogy is fascinating but no-one is responsible for their ancestors.
My friend’s family should not feel too guilty for helping Guy Fawkes although after the last year in politics, we can have some sympathy for wanting to blow up Parliament.