Dr Peter Moore: NHS reform could be suicidal for any political party

placeholder image

With all the strikes and unrest in the NHS, I’m not sure whether it’s reassuring or depressing to find that we are not alone. GPs in France are on strike. They are paid E25 for each consultation. They are asking for E50. The average in Europe is E45. Al

With all the strikes and unrest in the NHS, I’m not sure whether it’s reassuring or depressing to find that we are not alone.

GPs in France are on strike. They are paid E25 for each consultation. They are asking for E50. The average in Europe is E45.

Although patients are charged, they can claim it back from their health insurance. An increase in GPs costs would not affect the government but it would mean a higher insurance premium. France also has rural areas which are 'GP deserts' with no GP surgeries.

Here in the NHS, we have a different system. As in France, GPs here are self-employed and run their own practices as a business but they are not paid for each consultation. Payment depends on the number of registered patients.

This gives UK GPs an incentive to discourage patients from becoming dependent. If paid for every consultation, it is tempting to encourage people to come in whenever they have a minor virus.

In our system it does not affect the GP’s income whether patients visit every week or less than once a year.

Of course, being the NHS, it is not that simple. There are payments for hitting targets and different rates for the elderly. There are also complicated payments towards staff and other expenses.

Throughout the western world most healthcare is delivered through private health insurance but there is often a safety net for the poor. This was the system in the UK after 1911 when Lloyd George introduced the National Insurance Act.

Anyone earning less than £160 a year, about £15,000 today, paid in 4d a week, the employer had to pay 3d and the Government 2d. Lloyd George even produced a soundbite 'ninepence for fourpence'. He also introduced sick pay at 10s (50p) for 13 weeks then 5s (25p).

Patients who qualified for the scheme registered with a GP in a similar way to today’s NHS and were called 'panel patients'. Everyone else was a private patient. In 1948, the NHS allowed the whole population to be registered.

It is difficult to fit healthcare into a market economy. For most products people with more money can afford a more luxurious product such as a top-of-the-range Mercedes against a basic Hyundai or a £50 bottle of wine rather than the cheap plonk I buy.

The problem with healthcare is that the worse off have the worst outcomes with a lower life expectancy and more long-term serious illness. Any healthcare system has to be biased towards the poor, not the rich, which does not fit in with a market economy.

At the same time the population is getting older and medical care more expensive.

If the state can no longer afford universal healthcare for all, should we look at a private, insurance system, leaving the NHS for the poor who cannot afford the insurance premiums? This might mean that the very people who need the best care get the most basic care.

Also, if I pay £100 in insurance premium or £100 in tax towards healthcare, it is still £100 I do not have. Reducing tax and paying out to a private company is not saving money.

The NHS is struggling despite the amazing staff. The system is not working but the principle of the NHS is very popular. This puts all politicians in a difficult position. Reform of the NHS could be suicidal for any political party.

The NHS needs a long-term plan but elections are every five years or less. Ideally, we need an all-party commission looking at the NHS so that any proposed changes have the support of all parties and can be long term but this is politically naive.

The NHS is sick but France shows that a private insurance-based system is also flawed.

I still believe in the principle of the NHS, free at the point of need. After 75 years, it needs more funding and drastic reform but how can politicians tinker with such a sacred cow without committing electoral suicide?

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice