Dr Peter Moore: Levelling up should stop at one of our great institutions


I have just been to London for the first time since the lockdown. I was a student in London in the 1970s and knew it well but since then there have been one or two changes. London was buzzing, crowded with tourists from all over the world. They were cros
I have just been to London for the first time since the lockdown. I was a student in London in the 1970s and knew it well but since then there have been one or two changes.
London was buzzing, crowded with tourists from all over the world. They were crossing Westminster Bridge and taking pictures of Big Ben, which no one calls the Queen Elizabeth Tower.
The Tower of London held a fascination for the American tourists looking at a building 600 years older than their country. And many people come for the theatres and concerts in the West End.
There were even Christmas markets with a large Winter Wonderland being set up in Hyde Park.
We had tickets for the English National Opera’s (ENO) new production of Gilbert and Sullivan’s The Yeoman of the Guard. It was a brilliant production in one of London’s most iconic theatres, but it was also poignant. Not only is it the only G and S opera which is serious and ends in tragedy but the whole company is under threat.
The Arts Council will pull all their grants after next April unless they move north, probably to Manchester. This came as a surprise, even to Manchester. The Manchester mayor, Andy Burnham, the council and the theatres were not consulted. Neither was Opera North.
The ENO was founded as Sadler’s Wells and their sister company, Sadler’s Wells Ballet, has already moved from London to Birmingham.
What was different was that the Birmingham City Council and The Hippodrome theatre invited the ballet company to the city and it took four years of planning and negotiation. It is now the Birmingham Royal Ballet.
Moving an opera company is challenging. The musicians, singers, technical crew and numerous others have years of experience. It is not like moving a branch of McDonald's.
At the same time, Netflix and Disney are building new studios near London and many of the world’s biggest blockbusters are filmed here. South East England will soon make more movies than Hollywood. This is not because of the film stars but because we have a large number of behind-the-scenes experts.
Walking around London, I wondered whether levelling up should stop at opera companies. There are three cathedrals in central London, Southwark, St Paul’s and Westminster Abbey. Manchester only has one and this was only designated a cathedral in 1847. This is clearly unfair. Shouldn’t we move St Paul’s to Moss Side in Manchester?
And why has London got the River Thames and Manchester only the Manchester Ship Canal? Admittedly Liverpool has the Mersey and Newcastle the Tyne but this still feels unfair. Can’t we divert the Thames north?
One of the reasons for the growth of the South East throughout history is that it is nearer to the European continent. Why not close the Channel tunnel and build a new Channel tunnel from Newcastle? It would also mean moving St Pancreas Station, which is an amazing building.
Is there really a north-south divide? Other European countries such as France and Spain are also centralised to their capital, to the annoyance of Barcelona and the Catalans.
The problem here is not so much a north-south divide as London and the rest. Most of the UK do not seem to realise that there is a long peninsular beyond Bristol. Torbay is 100 miles from Bristol and almost 200 from London. Birmingham is less than 120 miles from London and, as far as I know, the main railway line to Birmingham has never been washed away by the sea. Plymouth is the same distance from London as Manchester.
How many of the tourists I saw in London would decide to go to Manchester, or even Plymouth, instead?
If we must move an iconic opera company away from London, how about using the Torquay Pavilion but it would be even better not to risk the future of one of our great institutions and support our capital city.