Dr Peter Moore: Let's hope strike action negotiations with nurses and teachers are as successful

placeholder image

With the cost-of-living crisis, is there anyone not threatening strike action? It is understandable. Unless workers are offered over ten per cent, they will suffer a cut in real terms which is not easy as all prices, especially energy, mortgage and rents

With the cost-of-living crisis, is there anyone not threatening strike action?

It is understandable. Unless workers are offered over ten per cent, they will suffer a cut in real terms which is not easy as all prices, especially energy, mortgage and rents, are shooting up.

At least the strike action by barristers has now been settled but how many people imagined that barristers would ever join in?

Their image is of a wealthy public school educated elite. As with all public images, this is not accurate.

I have faced several barristers across a courtroom, not as a criminal but as a police surgeon.

It is always popular to attack lawyers but outside the courtroom I have found them helpful and supportive even if, when facing them from the witness box, they would try to catch me out.

Someone training as a solicitor was told that if you go into criminal law you will not earn as much as your colleagues but you’ll have great anecdotes at dinner parties.

Unfortunately anecdotes do not pay the energy bills or the mortgage.

Barristers are self-employed. John Mortimer, a barrister and author of Rumpole, likened his job to a taxi for hire.

When a case is going to the crown court or they just need an opinion, solicitors will contact a barrister in the same way as they might hail a taxi.

They take on cases to defend or prosecute however difficult it might be. As WS Gilbert, himself a lawyer, put it in 1893: “Whether you’re an honest man or whether you’re a thief depends on whose solicitor has given me my brief.”

Gilbert might have been a little unfair on his own profession. If a client is clearly guilty a barrister will not argue he is innocent, just the mitigating circumstances.

But most criminals are not master minds living in a mansion like a James Bond villain. They have no money. Any payment comes from Legal Aid, ultimately the taxpayer.

The Criminal Bar Association claim that their real earnings have fallen by 28 per cent since 2006.

Before the strike a typical junior barrister would earn about £13,000 a year - less than the minimum wage. There are barristers earning less than baristas.

As a result, 22 per cent of junior barristers and 46 per cent of the senior barristers, KCs, have given up criminal work.

Briefs are often delivered late so that the barrister must work through the night to understand the case.

To make matters worse, payment can take a long time to come through.

As a result, there was a backlog of 60,000 cases before the strike action.

But does this affect the rest of us who are not criminals?

Justice being seen to be done is fundamental to our democracy. People accused of crimes are not criminals until proven beyond reasonable doubt in court.

If they pose a risk to the public or might abscond they are remanded in custody.

So prisons are filled with people who might not be guilty while there are people on the streets who might be guilty.

As the strike only affected Legal Aid, wealthy clients could pay for expensive top barristers leading to a two-tier system, the poor waited while the rich got their day in court.

The argument for nurses, teachers and many other public servants to have a substantial pay rise after years of relative falling pay is very strong.

Let’s hope the successful negotiations with the lawyers is followed by equally successful negotiations with nurses, teachers and others.

I would not recommend the alternative option for junior barristers to make money.

In Trial by Jury by Gilbert and Sullivan, the judge went through hard times but 'I soon got tired of third-class journeys and dinners of bread and water, so I fell in love with the rich attorney’s elderly, ugly daughter'.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice