Dr Peter Moore: Is retirement good for your health?


I remember a man who had been a successful CEO of a major international company. He could easily afford to retire in his early 50s. I saw him about ten years after retirement when he was looking at his watch. He looked worried. “What’s the problem?” “T
I remember a man who had been a successful CEO of a major international company. He could easily afford to retire in his early 50s.
I saw him about ten years after retirement when he was looking at his watch. He looked worried.
“What’s the problem?”
“The dustmen come today. They haven’t been yet. The bins are out the front and I can’t take them round the back until they are emptied.”
He had run a large multinational company and, ten years after retiring he was worried about the bins. There was no evidence of dementia or other problems. It is just that his world had dramatically shrunk since retirement.
Now Jeremy Hunt is suggesting that older people get off the golf course and get back to work. With the shortage of labour this might help the economy, but would it help the individual?
The idea of a set retirement age is relatively new. It was in 1881 that the German chancellor, Otto von Bismark, introduced a pension and forced retirement for anyone over 70.
In 1905, the Canadian doctor William Osler suggested that a man’s best work was before he was 40. He should retire by the age of 60. He did not mention women.
In 1911, Lloyd George introduced an old age pension for anyone over the age of 70. At the time life expectancy for men was 50 and even lower for manual labourers. Few people would live long enough to receive their pension.
But is early retirement bad for your health? A large study at Harvard University in America followed up 50-year-old workers with no known heart disease.
They found that people who retired were 40 per cent more likely to have a stroke or heart attack than those who carried on working. However, other studies found an improvement in health, largely through less stress and more exercise.
The problem is that we do not all do the same job so do not need to retire at the same age. Ideally, we should be able to retire slowly. Going part-time needs to be an option so why is the pension, both state and private all or nothing? Why can’t people opt for half their pension for a few years?
Many people who retire early do so due to ill health. No-one is suggesting forcing sick people back to work but, again, a sick note is all or nothing. Some people with health issues might be happy to work flexibly.
Older people often underestimate their skills. They come with a lifetime of experience with incredibly important soft skills firms are crying out for.
Slowing down and going part-time may not be an option for manual workers who are physically unable to carry on. And they already have a worse life expectancy.
When the time comes to retire, it might be worth asking whether it is possible to cut hours for a few years first but someone who is counting the days to retirement may not want to see the winning post moved.
If that does not appeal, can people find a role in life such as voluntary work?
One patient of mine who worked in finance all his life joined several voluntary organisations where he inevitably ended up as treasurer. He said to me: “The problem with being retired is that I don’t get a day off on Sundays.”
There was a recent study that suggested one important factor in staying healthy is to have friends and family. I saw several people who retired to Torquay. They had happy memories of holidays by the sea and a dream house with sea views sounded idyllic.
Sadly, they lost contact with their old friends and failed to find new ones. A sea view does not automatically bring happiness.
Not everyone is as lucky as I was. When I retired from my practice I carried on with locums and advisory work. After I fully retired, I found another option to keep the brain active which I recommend... writing columns in Torbay Weekly.