Dr Peter Moore: General practice or a GP version of A&E?


General practice has changed. In the 1970s, I was a GP trainee based in Plympton. We had a branch surgery in a village on the edge of Dartmoor. Dr Thompson had run this surgery for years but when he was away I was asked to cover. The surgery was in a h
General practice has changed.
In the 1970s, I was a GP trainee based in Plympton. We had a branch surgery in a village on the edge of Dartmoor.
Dr Thompson had run this surgery for years but when he was away I was asked to cover.
The surgery was in a hall with a small car park at the front.
I was told before going there that every patient would say: “Dr Thompson doesn’t do it like that.” My best bet would be to agree and copy anything that I was told Dr Thompson would do.
I was also told that the surgery finished at 10.30am.
All the patients knew the time it closed and they could all go to the main surgery.
It was important to get up and lock the door at 10.30am otherwise I’d be there all day.
I arrived and parked my car in front of the hall.
An elderly man walked over and tapped on my window. “Dr Thompson doesn’t park his car like that”.
This was before the days of GP computers and I was carrying a pile of notes from the main surgery.
People were supposed to make an appointment but whether I had the right notes was a bit hit and miss.
I only had my medical bag and a pile of prescription forms and so the medicine was also a bit basic.
The hall was used as the waiting room with a small side room as the consulting room.
I saw some patients and then, at about 10am, went to the door and shouted but the room was empty.
I managed to find the kettle and made a coffee, waiting for the next patient. No one arrived.
At 10.30am, I locked up and walked out to my car. An elderly man walked over.
“You the doctor?” he asked.
“Yes”
“Thompson not here then”
“I’m afraid not. Can I help?”
“Nope. I’ll pop back next week when he’s here. Thanks all the same.”
And off he walked.
I was later told that the villagers would walk to the hall and if it was not Dr Thompson’s car outside, they would go home and come back next week.
I drove off wondering whether I was a complete failure.
Would I ever be as popular as Dr Thompson?
I was also hoping that anyone waiting for Dr Thompson did not have a problem which needed urgent attention.
Today, post Covid and with general practice facing a crisis, it is often difficult to see any doctor despite the efforts of our local GPs.
My whole experience makes me wonder whether the current vogue for large GP surgeries when patients might see any doctor is the right way forward.
There has been a move to encourage same-day appointments and walk-in GP services but is this really general practice or simply a GP version of A&E?
After the tragedies of Dr Shipman, who murdered an unknown number of patients, single-handed GPs have been discouraged.
Dr Shipman was very popular with his patients but, with no other doctors, no one could see what he was doing.
Just because there was one terrible case it does not mean that all single-handed GPs were out of date, old fashioned or even mass murderers.
In the past we had several single-handed GPs in the Bay who were brilliant.
Whenever I visited them I came away feeling guilty. They were highly organised, knew their patients very well and provided a superb service.
These practices were not really ‘single-handed’.
There may have only been one doctor but all the staff and the practice nurse were important members of the team.
Dr Thompson running a weekly surgery in a village was not really a single-handed GP but he developed a loyalty that most GPs can only dream of.
Whenever I park my car I still wonder whether Dr Thompson ‘doesn’t park his car like that’.
Written by Dr Peter Moore, former Bay GP