Dr Peter Moore: Disagreement is a vital part of a free society


When I started writing I made a terrible mistake. I wrote what I thought was a harmless but quite interesting article about the history of the contraceptive pill. When discussing its development I just mentioned in passing about an animal experiment. I h
When I started writing I made a terrible mistake. I wrote what I thought was a harmless but quite interesting article about the history of the contraceptive pill.
When discussing its development I just mentioned in passing about an animal experiment. I have never made that mistake again.
The paper was inundated with angry letters. The editor published a whole page of them and asked me to write a reply. I knew I had to be tactful and wrote about how important it was not to be cruel to animals and show them respect. But I finished by daring to suggested that, although we must not deliberately inflict pain on any animal, if I had to choose between a human or an animal I would choose a human.
We then had another tsunami of angry letters. Another mistake.
Fortunately, this was many years ago when doctors were not allowed to use their name when writing in the press. It was just 'a doctor writes'. And there was no internet or social media or it might have gone into overdrive.
They seemed to think that I was worse than Vlad the Impaler who killed about 80,000 people. I suppose he had a method of population control without resorting to animal experiments.
Sadly, there are still no-go areas for many writers. J K Rowling has been ostracised for her views on the transgender issues. The academic historian and priest Professor Biggar’s book on the British Empire was initially turned down by publishers as it was not totally negative.
Roald Dahl has now been bowdlerised by sensitivity readers taking out his more challenging expressions when his ability to write close to the edge was one of his strengths.
Ian Fleming’s James Bond books are being republished to commemorate the 70th anniversary of the Casino Royale, the first Bond book but not before some revision. In fairness, Ian Fleming was a man of his time, misogynistic, homophobic and racist. No one would support the use of the N word today. I remember in Moonraker he attacks all short people. I wonder whether this has been cut to avoid heightism.
The Newsnight journalist Hannah Barnes’s book on the problems of the gender clinic at Tavistock Square was rejected by 22 publishers before being accepted despite many of these publishers praising the proposal.
The book was an objective look at the care given by the clinic and not anti-trans people but was still considered too hot to handle. It might upset their other authors and one publisher even suggested that the junior staff would object. I began to wonder what the word 'junior' meant. I cannot imagine overruling the decisions of my consultant when I was a junior doctor.
Open discussion and disagreement are a vital part of a free society. I may disagree with the political views of some of my friends but that does not stop us being friends. They may be right. Besides my views are boringly middle of the road. It is difficult to march waving a banner saying, 'on the one hand, on the other hand it may or may not be a good idea'. Or 'I demand procrastination - sometime in the next few weeks or perhaps longer'.
I was also pleased to see Lord Hague, the former leader of the Conservatives, producing a joint report with Tony Blair. They may have had robust arguments over the dispatch box in the past but they can still work together. I got the impression that they may even be friends.
When Rishi Sunak became Prime Minister he contacted Kier Starmer, they swopped personal mobile phone numbers and agreed to work together in areas they agree. This does not stop them attacking each other in the Commons.
Hopefully, no one at Torbay Weekly plans to send my column to sensitivity readers although since my howler mentioning animal experiments, I am careful. I do have a book at home from the 1950s called 'Enid Blyton’s Gay Stories'. If it is ever republished they may need to change the name.