Brixham Museum trustees defend volunteer suspensions amid governance row


New board responds to claims of exclusion and calls for transparency, saying changes were vital for the museum’s future stability
The new trustees of Brixham Heritage Museum have responded to an open letter from former volunteers who say they were hurt and distressed after their memberships were suspended in 2022.
The trustees claimed “misinformation” had been circulated and defended their actions as necessary for the museum’s future.
Eight volunteers, whose memberships were suspended in 2022, protested at an extraordinary general meeting held on 3 February 2025. They claim they were denied entry to the meeting despite having paid for 2025 membership and having longstanding links to the museum.
At the meeting, a proposal to change the museum’s structure was approved. It will move from a traditional membership charity to a Foundation Charitable Incorporated Organisation (CIO), a model in which trustees are appointed rather than elected by members.
The suspended volunteers claim the change removes “the rights of the people of Brixham to vote on how the museum and its assets are managed in the future.” They also claim that their preferred membership model was not selected so that the trustees could avoid being held accountable for the suspensions.
The trustees said the decision followed “a thorough review of professional advice and best practices within the museum sector”.
They also said the suspension of seven volunteers — and the permanent exclusion of one — was “not made lightly” but was part of efforts to “ensure the museum’s long-term stability and alignment with ethical governance”.
The museum, which dates back to 1958, is mainly run by volunteers and has relied on community fundraising for support.
In a letter to the board, the suspended volunteers described being barred from the EGM as “hurtful” and said they had given years of unpaid service to the museum, including helping to build exhibits. Among them is Barbara Davies, 92, who had volunteered at the museum for more than 20 years. They claim they have still not been given written reasons for their suspension.
In a statement, the museum said it faced “significant internal difficulties” before November 2022, including a work culture that had “become increasingly challenging for staff and trustees”.
However, the volunteers insist that their work as the museum’s fundraising group did not in any way contribute to a difficult work environment. They say it was the high turnover of paid staff that presented challenges, together with the pandemic.
The trustees also cited high staff turnover, reductions in public funding — including a 50 per cent cut from Torbay Council and a 100 per cent cut from Brixham Town Council — and governance concerns that risked its museum accreditation, which is required for external grants.
Legal advice, the trustees said, supported the need to take “necessary steps to restore a healthy, functional, and professional working environment”.
Mediation with independent mediators was offered to the suspended volunteers, according to the museum, but was declined several times.
The volunteers said they found the idea of individual mediation “intimidating and stressful” and had instead requested a group meeting with trustees after asking for written details of any allegations against them. They also claim that mediation was only offered to them on one occasion more than two years after the suspensions. The trustees said individual mediation was designed to “allow individuals to respond to allegations without prejudice, avoid the pitfalls of group dynamics, and share personal confidential information without fear of reprisals”. They said communications about mediation were sent out “on multiple occasions”.
The trustees said the museum has since embarked on a “structured path of renewal”, including updating its constitution, appointing a new board, implementing governance reforms, and investigating past issues.
They said that “continued efforts to disrupt the museum’s progress” had damaged its reputation and ability to secure funding but added that their focus was on rebuilding trust within the community and ensuring the museum remains “inclusive, well-managed and professionally run”.
The suspended volunteers said they still care deeply about the museum and hope it will flourish under new guidance. However, they continue to request written explanations for their suspension, which the museum says have already been provided.