Plymouth Argyle awards night celebrates heroes as bigger battles still await


Plymouth Argyle’s 2025/26 awards night celebrated standout men’s and women’s stars, from Alex Mitchell to Phoebie Poole, as both teams continue chasing season-defining success
Plymouth Argyle celebrated the best of its men’s and women’s teams at the 2025/26 end-of-season awards night, recognising standout performers, breakthrough youngsters and key figures behind the scenes after a memorable campaign across the club.
With the Men’s team still pushing for a League One play-off spot and the Women’s preparing for an FA Women’s National League play-off final against Wolverhampton Wanderers, the evening reflected both achievement so far and the promise of even bigger moments still to come.
Men’s Awards
Supporters’ Player of the Season - Alex Mitchell
‘Never fall in love with a loan player’ - the Home Park faithful certainly have with the Charlton man.
Alex became a fan favourite thanks to his commanding defensive displays, aerial dominance and consistent partnership with Mathias Ross at the heart of defence.
Mitchell’s leadership, huge clearances tally and knack for big moments made him a deserved fan choice.
Players’ Player of the Season - Malachi Boateng
Boateng’s ever-present midfield role made him indispensable. Starting every league game, he has been Argyle’s engine, blending defensive grit, physical presence and creativity with goals and assists. His consistency earned him the recognition from his peers.
Supporters’ Young Player of the Season - Tegan Finn
The teenage winger’s breakthrough season showed flashes of exciting potential.
While still developing, Finn’s attacking approach and strong cup performances, scoring 3 in 5 in the EFL Trophy, gave supporters a glimpse of a promising academy product.
Breakthrough Prospect - Seb Campbell
Campbell’s record-breaking goal against Tottenham Hotspur U21 made history, with the teenager becoming Argyle’s youngest goalscorer aged 16 years and 279 days.
His emergence marks him as one of the club’s brightest future prospects.
Community Player of the Season - Julio Pleguezuelo
Recognised for his work with Argyle 4 Autism, Julio’s impact off the pitch has been profound.
Despite injury, his dedication to community support and personal commitment to the cause made this one of the night’s most meaningful awards.
Men’s Goal of the Season - Team Goal vs Wigan Athletic (finished by Bim Pepple)
A sweeping move that involved eight of the ten outfield Argyle players, Pepple’s finish captured the team’s attacking identity and was voted the standout strike of the season.
Women’s Awards
Supporters’ Player of the Season - Phoebie Poole
With 16 goals, Phoebie has led from the front as Argyle Women’s top scorer, delivering crucial goals throughout a superb campaign.
Her attacking consistency has been central to the Greens’ title challenge and promotion push.
Players’ Player of the Season - Ellie Noble
Club captain Ellie Noble has combined leadership with elite end product, scoring 14 goals while setting standards across the squad.
Her influence, quality and leadership made her the players’ standout choice.
Supporters’ Young Player of the Season - Tianna Teisar
Tianna’s remarkable 13-goal campaign underlined her immense potential.
Her rise has added another dangerous attacking dimension and highlighted Argyle Women’s strength for the future.
Women’s Manager’s Award - Jan Augustynowicz (Kit and Equipment Lead)
Jan’s recognition reflected her enormous contribution behind the scenes.
Widely praised by players and supporters alike, her tireless work and importance to the squad culture made her a hugely popular winner.
Moment of the Season - Last-Minute Win at AFC Bournemouth
Una Lue’s 90+2 winner in the dramatic 2-1 victory at Bournemouth, defined as ‘season-defining’ by many, has proved a huge result that preserved Argyle’s promotion hopes and showcased the team’s resilience.
Jack Leslie Respect Award - Lulu Jarvis
Despite suffering a serious leg break early in the campaign, Lulu remained a vital presence within the squad during the promotion push.
Her resilience and continued contribution embodied the spirit of the award.
Women’s Goal of the Season - Ellie Noble vs Oxford United
Ellie’s stunning free-kick against Oxford earned its Goal of the Season honour, combining technical quality with a moment supporters won’t forget.