Battle to stop controversial turbine cable plans is lost as legal bid rejected

The legal bid to prevent wind turbine cables coming ashore at Saunton Sands has failed after a judge turned down an application for a judicial review. Credit: Alison Stephensonplaceholder image
The legal bid to prevent wind turbine cables coming ashore at Saunton Sands has failed after a judge turned down an application for a judicial review. Credit: Alison Stephenson

A plea for a judicial review of White Cross plans to bring undersea turbine cables ashore at Saunton Sands has been rejected

Campaigners trying to stop wind turbine cables coming on shore at Saunton Sands beach have given up their legal fight after a judicial review was rejected.

After more than two years of fighting, campaign groups Love Braunton and Save Our Sands saw their request for a judicial review of the controversial White Cross scheme turned down by a judge at Cardiff Courts.

Love Braunton said it was “bitterly disappointed” at the outcome following the two-and-a half-hour hearing but accepted that the decision was “final.”

Save Our Sands (SOS) said it had “exhausted the process” but has vowed to hold the White Cross project developers and North Devon Council to account over the various planning conditions imposed on the scheme.placeholder image
Save Our Sands (SOS) said it had “exhausted the process” but has vowed to hold the White Cross project developers and North Devon Council to account over the various planning conditions imposed on the scheme.

Above: Campaigners argued the cable plans could cause irreparable harm to Saunton and the surrounding protected areas including the estuary and biosphere. Credit: SOS

Efforts began in October 2023 to try and stop a planning application to site the cables for the offshore 100 megawatt windfarm 31 miles off the North Devon coast, with the cables to come ashore at Saunton Sands and be tunnelled under several miles of protected landscape.

The cables will carry power from a ‘test and demonstration’ windfarm of up to eight turbines, which White Cross says will power up to 135,000 homes, but the route will go through a host of protected landscapes before connecting to the national grid at East Yelland, where a new substation will be built.

Opponents said their mission was to save the potential destruction of protected habits such the Braunton Burrows dune system – a UNESCO biosphere reserve – and local tourism and prevent industrialisation of the area.

A petition of almost 4,000 names and 1,800 letters were submitted to North Devon Council objecting to the plans, but the application was approved in May 2025 with 39 conditions.

Last year Save Our Sands recreated Pink Floyd’s album cover shot for A Momentary Lapse of Reason from 48 years ago at Saunton beach with a slogan asking ‘North Devon Council… was this a momentary lapse of reason?’.placeholder image
Last year Save Our Sands recreated Pink Floyd’s album cover shot for A Momentary Lapse of Reason from 48 years ago at Saunton beach with a slogan asking ‘North Devon Council… was this a momentary lapse of reason?’.

Above: One protest saw a small scale recreation of the Pink Floyd album cover for A Momentary Lapse of Reason, which was shot at Saunton 48 years ago. Credit: Liz Seymour

With the community’s help more than £50,000 was raised to challenge the legality of the council’s decision after campaigners said the process was ‘deeply flawed’, the application lacked information and the council had failed to properly consider objections.

On its Facebook page this week Love Braunton, which applied for the judicial review, said the judge had considered all of the points made during the course of the hearing and gave reasoned arguments for his decision based on the relevant case law.

He accepted that North Devon Council’s planning committee ‘was composed of experienced local councillors who had the time to read the detailed paperwork’ and that council officers were entitled to rely on Natural England’s consultation responses in helping them reach a decision.

Love Braunton said after: “Although bitterly disappointed with this outcome we have accepted that this decision is final.

“Whilst it is the end of this chapter in the White Cross saga the next stage is the pending applications to be made in respect of the conditions.”

Both groups have thanked the ‘amazing’ community without whom they could not have made the legal challenge.

Helen Cooper from Save Our Sands said while they did not agree with the outcome, they respected it.

She said it was encouraging their campaign had been included in Exeter University’s policy research study for the Marine Management Organisation, which granted the licence for the windfarm, which was due to be published later this year.

She added: “Our inclusion in their Sustainable Futures Conference on how we can disagree about green energy projects was also very welcome.

“Hopefully the efforts we have made to protect our area and community from unfair exploitation will benefit other communities from having to endure a similar experience.

“Thanks to everyone who continues to support our campaign and  who’ve contributed to the legal challenge fundraiser.

“Our efforts to protect this internationally important and highly designated area will continue through the public consultations on all the post consent conditions

“This area is too important to simply stand by and watch its degradation in the name of profit and progress.”placeholder image
“This area is too important to simply stand by and watch its degradation in the name of profit and progress.”

Above: Campaign groups Save and Sands and Love Braunton have both organised numerous protests at the beach to fight against the White Cross cable plans. 

During the planning process Flotation Energy, the company behind the White Cross project, adapted its plans to ‘minimise environmental and social impacts’.

It said the UK was already a leader in floating offshore wind technology, but until now this had only been via projects in Scottish waters.

Planning approval in North Devon gave it the opportunity to “harness this pioneering technology to help deliver the energy transition in the south west of England.”

It said: “By doing so, we will seek to spark the development of a specialised local supply chain, creating jobs whilst providing 135,000 homes with renewable energy.”

The company said once the White Cross cables make landfall at Saunton, they will be completely buried underground for their entire length and will travel approximately eight kilometres to a new White Cross onshore substation, which will accommodate the connection to the existing East Yelland substation.

It added: “The cables will pass beneath Braunton Burrows and the Taw Estuary via trenchless technology, designed to avoid any surface disruption within the Braunton Burrows Special Area of Conservation (SAC) dune system and the Taw-Torridge Estuary SSSI.

“White Cross is a stepping stone project that is pivotal to the Crown Estate’s ambitions to scale-up and commercialise floating energy technologies in the Celtic Sea.”

The project supports the UK Government’s target for offshore wind, alongside wider decarbonisation and energy security targets.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice